HOA Karen Tried to Ban Kids From the Playground — Then Half the Neighborhood Signed Against Her

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Potential future concern translated into present authority.

“What inspection found it unsafe?” I asked.

Linda snapped, “You do not have standing.”

“Then answer Martin.”

She turned toward him.

“The board has a responsibility to protect the association.”

Martin held out his hand.

“Show me the inspection.”

Linda’s grip tightened around the clipboard.

“There hasn’t been a formal one yet.”

Carol laughed.

“So you closed the playground before the safety review you claimed was happening?”

“I acted preventively.”

“Without board approval,” Martin said.

Linda’s face changed.

That was the first time I saw her understand that Martin was no longer automatically standing beside her.

She looked around at the residents.

“You all think this is about children playing. It isn’t. It is about standards. Property values. Insurance. Liability. Quiet enjoyment.”

A little boy near the slide whispered, “We’re quiet.”

His mother put an arm around him.

Linda heard.

For one second, something almost human crossed her face.

Then it hardened.

“The board meeting is Friday,” she said. “We can settle it properly.”

She walked away.

Friday night filled the clubhouse.

More people attended than had attended the last annual meeting.

Linda sat in the front row with a binder thick enough to suggest either excellent preparation or desperation.

Martin called the meeting to order.

The first item was the playground.

Linda immediately stood.

“I move that the board authorize permanent removal of the obsolete recreation equipment based on nuisance concerns, safety exposure, and declining community standards.”

Martin looked at the secretary.

“No board member has made that motion.”

Linda flushed.

“I am presenting the committee recommendation.”

“Then present it.”

She did.

For fifteen minutes.

Noise.

Maintenance.

Possible injury.

Insurance rates.

Aesthetic decline.

Potential resident complaints.

She presented photographs of kids playing basketball.

A stroller beside a bench.

Sidewalk chalk.

A water bottle left near the slide.

Evidence, apparently, of civilization collapsing.

Then she introduced the beautification concept.

Landscape beds.

Benches.

Walking path.

No playground.

Cost estimate.

Mercer Outdoor Living.

Martin interrupted.

“Before you continue, is Mercer Outdoor Living owned by your son?”

The room went silent.

Linda looked at him.

“He is one of the owners.”

“Did you disclose that when you presented the proposal?”

“I assumed everyone knew.”

“I didn’t.”

“That is hardly relevant.”

“It is extremely relevant.”

Linda’s cheeks reddened.

“My son’s company submitted a competitive concept.”

“How many other bids?”

Pause.

“None yet.”

“So not competitive.”

She shut the binder.

“This is becoming personal.”

I stood when homeowner comments opened.

I placed the petition on the table.

Fifty-three signatures.

More than three quarters of occupied homes.

“These residents are not asking the board to ignore safety,” I said. “They’re asking the board to distinguish evidence from one person’s preference.”

I handed Martin a short packet.

Page one: quiet-hour rule.

Page two: playground designation in community documents.

Page three: prior failed removal proposals.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Tried to Ban Kids From the Playground — Then Half the Neighborhood Signed Against Her

10 Part