At home that afternoon, Riley was less charitable about strategy. She had been asked by her parents to write her own statement for the board because Cynthia had touched her shoulder. Riley's first draft began: "Cynthia Bell decided the Constitution ended at the curb of Juniper Court."
Nathan read the first sentence and pushed the paper back.
"What?" Riley asked.
"Write what happened."
"That is what happened emotionally."
"The board is not reviewing the Constitution."
"Cowards."
Owen laughed despite himself.
Riley rewrote it: "I crouched to pick up Owen's sewing tin after the wagon tipped. Cynthia told me to step back. I said I was picking up the tin. She put her hand on my shoulder and moved me to the side. I did not fall. I told her not to touch me."
Nathan nodded. "Perfect."
"It has no personality."
"It has facts."
"Same problem."
Owen helped her finish. For the first time since Halloween, the work made him feel useful without feeling watched.
Tuesday brought an unexpected complication. Colin Mercer, the property manager, called Nathan to say the HOA's insurance advisor wanted clarification about the Costume Rescue setup. Not because a claim had been filed, but because the board was reviewing whether a child-run station with pins and tools should have been allowed at all.
Cynthia had raised the question before Halloween and again after.
Nathan put the call on speaker with Owen in the room, though he told Maisie to finish homework elsewhere. "So even if she handled it wrong, they might ban the wagon next year?"
Colin answered carefully. "The board can adopt reasonable event rules. They're looking at what those should be. That doesn't determine whether Cynthia had authority to move your property last week."
Owen listened from the table.
Nathan said, "What does the insurer actually recommend?"
"Adult supervision, no exposed blades, clear work area, no repairs involving vision obstruction, breathing, or structural mobility aids, and parents should approve modifications."
Owen frowned. "We already did almost all of that."
Colin heard him. "I know. That's in my notes."
"Do they say kids can't help?"
"No."
"Do they say it has to be an official HOA station?"
"No."
Nathan asked, "Anything about the sign?"
"Nothing."
Owen looked at his father. Nathan looked back.
The sign had never been a safety issue.
That night, Nathan explained the insurer's advice to the children. Maisie responded by rewriting the card for the wagon: ASK A PARENT BEFORE PINNING, CUTTING, OR FIXING ANYTHING NEAR YOUR FACE. Riley wanted to add OR INVOLVING HOA POLITICS. She was overruled.
Owen did not tell them he had started imagining next Halloween again.
He was not ready to admit it.
Wednesday evening, Harold Bishop came to the Fletcher garage. He was seventy-two, tall, slightly stooped, and wore a blue work jacket with a pencil tucked behind one ear. He examined the wagon wheel for less than a minute before saying, "Bracket's bent. Axle's fine."
Nathan said, "That's what I thought."