"Look at this," Patricia said. "Hooks everywhere. Line everywhere."
"They're in a box."
"Don't be smart with me."
"That's my grandpa's."
"Then your grandfather should know better."
She tipped the box onto the muddy slope.
Lily gasped.
Bobbers bounced through the grass. A small packet of hooks slid into the mud. The spool of spare line rolled toward the edge before Eli trapped it with his sneaker.
Caleb stared at the scattered tackle.
"Why did you do that?"
"Because I'm tired of explaining this."
He reached for his rod.
Patricia got there first.
She grabbed it by the blank and lifted it.
"Give it back."
Caleb held the handle lightly with one hand. He did not yank. Walter had taught him never to pull hard against somebody holding a rod because graphite and fiberglass could snap without warning.
"Let go," Patricia said.
"It's mine."
"It is being used in violation of a committee directive."
"There isn't a directive."
Her face changed.
She pulled.
Caleb let go.
The sudden lack of resistance made her take a half step backward. Instead of returning the rod, she swung her arm toward the water and threw it.
The rod landed with a splash less than ten feet from the bank. The reel sank first. The red tag remained above the surface for a few seconds before the rod settled against the reeds.
Lily screamed, "That was Grandpa's!"
Eli moved toward the water.
Patricia grabbed the strap of his backpack and pulled him backward. "Stay out of there!"
Eli stumbled but caught himself.
That was when Walter stood.
The newspaper fell from his lap.
"Get your hands off the kids."
Patricia released the strap and turned. "You should have been supervising them."
"I was."
"Then you're the problem too."
Walter walked toward her, not fast, not threatening, but with the kind of stillness that made Lily stop crying for a moment.
"You threw his property in the lake."
"I removed prohibited equipment."
"You invented the prohibition."
"The lake is under review."
"The fish are under review," Walter said. "Your authority isn't."
A utility cart hummed along the trail before Patricia could answer.
Arthur Collins, Willow Creek's seventy-two-year-old groundskeeper, was driving toward the maintenance shed with a rake and a trash grabber strapped behind the seat. Arthur had worked around the community longer than most residents had lived there. He had repaired docks, cleared storm drains, planted trees, and probably knew every broken sprinkler head by location.
He slowed when he saw the people clustered at the bank.
"What's going on?"
Lily pointed. "She threw Caleb's rod in!"
Arthur climbed out of the cart and looked toward the reeds. The rod had drifted slightly, but the red plastic tag was still visible near the surface.
Arthur's expression changed.
He walked to the water's edge and squinted.
"Walter," he said slowly, "where'd you get that rod?"
Walter looked at him. "You gave it to me."
Arthur stared for another second.
Then he laughed once, not because anything was funny but because recognition had hit him unexpectedly.
"I'll be damned."
Patricia crossed her arms. "What does that have to do with anything?"