There's a liability angle. If any of her business inventory had been damaged while in my garage, she'd have had no legal standing to claim it because the arrangement was undisclosed and uncompensated. And then there's what Pete called the cleanest angle of all, unjust enrichment. Unjust enrichment is exactly what it sounds like. Ohio civil law recognizes that when one person receives a substantial benefit at another person's direct expense without compensation or legal justification, the court can order them to pay for what they took.
Eight months of commercial storage at even a modest market rate, $100 a month, conservative for a climate controlled space, plus the displaced vehicle costs, plus the wrongful fine, put Derek's recoverable damages in small claims court somewhere between $1,200 and $1,500. Ohio Small Claims handles disputes up to $6,000. No attorney required. Filing fee under $100. Show up with your documentation and tell the truth.
I'd read once that small claims court was designed specifically so that ordinary people with legitimate grievances wouldn't need to hire expensive lawyers to recover what they were owed. Sitting on that stool in my half- reclaimed garage, I finally understood what that meant from the inside. Pete finished his summary, I thanked him. We hung up. I sat there for another minute in the quiet.
The bare bulb overhead, the pegboard on the wall with every tool in its labeled outline. the half of the garage that was still mine, still organized, still exactly right. Then I thought about Constance measuring cargo space on her phone, planning to walk in here and take everything back without a word, without a dollar, without a single acknowledgement of what 8 months had actually cost me. I picked up my phone, opened Facebook Marketplace. This time, I started typing.
The listing took me 45 minutes to write. Not because I didn't know what to say. I knew exactly what to say, but because I wanted every word to be right. I'd spent the previous evening confirming with Pete that what I was about to do was legally defensible from every angle. He walked me through it one more time slowly, the way you explain a load calculation to an apprentice who needs to understand it before he touches the pipe.
The 14-day cure period had elapsed. Written notice had been properly served and confirmed delivered. My documented costs, $480 in parking, $150 in wrongful fines, and a conservative $800 in fair market commercial storage value at going rates for a climate controlled residential space totaled well over the assessed value of the staged furniture and boxes sitting in my garage. Under Ohio's possessory lien provisions, disposal through reasonable means was legally permissible. I wasn't stealing.