The board voted to table the amendment pending a narrower draft and a review of the existing architectural rules. Meredith objected, but the motion carried. Daniel thought the meeting might end there. He had already achieved the practical goal of protecting the cameras while the criminal complaint proceeded. Nora touched his arm and whispered that they could go home if he wanted. Daniel looked down at the third folder, the one filled with fines, minutes, and letters that never answered his questions. He stood again.
"There's one more issue," he said. Harold closed his eyes for a brief moment as though he had expected the sentence all evening. Daniel held up the eleven notices. "Over five months my wife and I received more than six hundred dollars in fines. I paid some because I was new and thought they had been properly authorized. I challenged others and requested the board decisions approving them. I've reviewed the minutes I was provided, and I cannot find a vote for a single one."
He quoted the bylaws carefully, identifying the section requiring notice and a board decision before penalties were entered. He described the management company's explanation that invoices were generated when an authorized representative submitted them. He showed the dates of each alleged violation, the dates the board had met, and the absence of matching recorded action. Then he turned toward Harold. "I'm not asking whether you think the complaints were reasonable," he said. "I'm asking whether the board voted on these penalties as our governing documents require."
Harold stared at the table. The treasurer shifted uneasily beside him. He asked for a moment to consult the secretary, who shook her head as she looked at the binder in front of her. Finally he raised his eyes. "No," he said. "We did not vote on each of those fines. Meredith had been submitting them through the normal process, and we didn't review them individually." Daniel let the answer remain in the air. He had imagined feeling vindicated when he heard it. Instead he felt suddenly sad that the simplest question had taken five months and a room full of people to answer.
June Talbot rose from the second row with a letter in her hand. "Then what about my mailbox?" she asked. Harold looked confused. June explained that she had paid two hundred dollars in penalties after repainting a mailbox in the original approved color, because the notice said she would otherwise face collection. A man behind her asked about a basketball hoop. Another woman mentioned a garden border that Meredith had declared the wrong height. The questions began to overlap, not in anger alone but in the shock of people discovering that they had accepted the same private humiliation separately.
Frances asked the crowd to speak one at a time. Walter wrote a list of addresses and amounts on his notebook pad. A resident from the north loop said Meredith had once threatened a lien over a thirty-dollar lawn notice. Another recalled receiving a fee for leaving holiday decorations up two days after the alleged removal deadline, despite there being no such date in the posted rules. The treasurer was distressed. Money paid through the portal had been deposited in the association account, not Meredith's personal account, but that did not make the charges proper. The funds had entered the budget, and some had already been spent on ordinary neighborhood maintenance.