HOA Karen Smashed My Security Camera — Then a Deputy Watching the Livestream Called It In

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The vote was 84 to 7. Brenda didn't say another word. She collected her printed agendas, the one she'd brought, the ones that told the story she'd planned to tell tonight, and she put them in her tote bag, and she walked out the side door of the community center. The door clicked shut behind her. Nobody called after her.

The room watched her go the way you watch a weather system move off, with relief and a kind of exhausted wonder that it's finally over. In the parking lot, according to Gail Thurston, who followed her out, Brenda sat in her pearl white Cadillac for 11 minutes before she drove away. Gail was gracious enough not to photograph it, but she took careful notes on what she saw, and she told me about it a week later over coffee. And I have to tell you, despite everything, it didn't feel triumphant. It felt like what it was, a woman who had used power badly finally out of power.

What felt triumphant was Chuck Dolan grabbing my shoulder in the parking lot afterward, and squeezing it hard without saying anything. What felt triumphant was Walt Beaumont, who I found in a corner of the community center after most people had filtered out, sitting with Shirley. And Walt was crying a little. He said, "The garden marker's still there. She never made us take it down, just fined us for it.

It can stay,"I told him. " It was always supposed to stay." The legal resolution took about 4 months to fully close out. The civil complaint settled, not in court, but out of it, under terms that the HOA's insurance carrier drove, once they reviewed the full financial picture. The $2,000 lien against my property was formally vacated.

The camera fines were dismissed. The HOA's legal fees, going back to the improperly noticed emergency session, were waived. Brenda's $38,000 in personal consulting contracts was subject to a separate negotiated restitution arrangement that I was not privy to. But Dale's understanding, based on what the carrier communicated, was that it was not comfortable for her. The criminal mischief complaint ran its course through the system.

I was not the complainant. Deputy Ostrander had filed the initial report and the sheriff's office handled it from there. The case resulted in a misdemeanor conviction, a fine and community service. I did not attend the sentencing. I didn't need to.

Dale's attorney's fees were covered under the court's award. Ohio 5312.09 allows for fee shifting when an HOA's actions are found improper. He sent me a final bill that showed a zero balance, which remains one of the most satisfying pieces of paper I have ever received. I framed it. It's in the garage next to my electrician's license.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Smashed My Security Camera — Then a Deputy Watching the Livestream Called It In

15 Part