At home Nathan and Abby arranged the material across the dining table. The missing vote records concerned them more than the amounts, because a small unauthorized fine remained unauthorized even if it was accurately deposited. Abby noticed the latest notice carried a signature block that referred to Deborah as "Director of Community Compliance," though the board had never created such an office. She asked why nobody had corrected that title. Nathan said people who were busy paying mortgages and taking children to school tended to assume an official-looking letter had been reviewed by someone with authority. Abby said that assumption was exactly what made the system dangerous. They agreed to ask the entire board, not Deborah alone, to account for it.
A few days before the scheduled meeting, Martin came to their porch. His shoulders were lower than Nathan remembered, and he held his keys tightly in one hand. He said the board had obtained legal advice and was concerned that enforcing Deborah's proposed camera amendment during an active criminal case would look retaliatory. Nathan asked why a criminal case was necessary for the board to notice that the proposal lacked a reasonable factual basis. Martin admitted that the board had been avoiding conflict for years. He said Deborah handled most correspondence because she volunteered to do it, and the rest of the directors rarely looked beyond the monthly financial summary. Nathan replied that volunteers did not stop being accountable because no one paid them.
Martin sat down when Abby offered him a chair. He told them he had not personally voted to assess Nathan's penalties. He also admitted that he knew Deborah had sent fines without waiting for recorded votes but had assumed residents could appeal them if they disagreed. Abby asked how a resident could appeal a decision that had never been made by the board. Martin studied his keys and said he did not have a good answer. He wanted the meeting to be calm. Nathan said calm would be easier if the directors acknowledged the problem rather than forcing homeowners to argue for every inch of honesty. Martin promised to bring the records and answer questions.
The meeting took place in the recreation center's multipurpose room. Usually fewer than fifteen owners attended, and several of those came mainly for the cookies. That Thursday nearly ninety people filled the folding chairs, with others standing along the walls. The management company had arranged a microphone and projector after Gus warned that attendance would be unusually high. Deborah arrived early in a dark jacket and sat near the front with a thick folder of papers. Nathan noticed she had placed a large privacy sign beside her chair. He also noticed that Abby was holding his hand so tightly he could feel her pulse.