The bat slipped from Celeste's hand. It hit the driveway with a ringing metallic clatter and rolled in a slow circle before coming to rest near the front tire of the Range Rover. For the first time since she had arrived, she looked directly at Isaiah rather than at the story she had built around him. Her face drained so fast it seemed to take years off her makeup and ten off her voice.
"That is impossible," she whispered.
Wade released Isaiah as if the fabric of Isaiah's shirt had suddenly become hot enough to burn. He looked from Celeste to the McLaren, then to the large bronze numbers beside the front door, then back to Isaiah. All at once the scene rearranged itself for him. The homeowner he had physically restrained without proper cause. The luxury car he had treated as probable evidence instead of property. The woman with the bat. The child on the porch. The phones filming from the street.
"Mr. Monroe," he began, and stopped because whatever he had intended to say could not survive the facts now visible in front of him.
Isaiah rubbed his shoulder and stepped away from the car. He kept his hands low and open where everyone could see them. He did not trust Wade enough to move any other way. "My driver's license is in my left front pocket," he said evenly. "My house key is in my right. My wallet also contains the registration and insurance card for the car you watched her destroy. My daughter is inside my house. My home cameras are recording. And if you speak to me again before reading me my rights or apologizing, I suggest you choose your words with more care than you chose your assumptions."
Celeste still held the phone to her ear. Arnold was speaking rapidly now, almost certainly asking what she had done. She ended the call without answering him. "Isaiah," she said, trying his first name as though they were acquaintances recovering from a misunderstanding at a garden party, "there has clearly been a terrible confusion."
He looked at the spiderwebbed windshield, the wrecked headlight, the glass across his seats, and the bat at her feet. "A confusion does not usually involve four deliberate swings."
Sirens sounded faintly at the entrance to the development. Someone on the street had called 911 independently, and unlike Celeste's first report, the second one had probably mentioned an assault and property damage. Celeste followed the sound with widening eyes. The confidence she wore at board meetings and charity auctions had always rested on the assumption that if something went wrong she would be the first person believed. For perhaps the first time in years, she understood what it felt like to lose control of the story before she had framed it.