It was the first time Denise had mentioned the project since the hearing. “Thanks.”
“Less cluttered.”
Of course, Avery thought. She almost laughed.
Denise stood and brushed soil from her gloves. “I saw the mock-up on the board website. The text is clearer.”
“Lucas suggested words.”
Denise nodded. “Good suggestion.”
Avery waited, uncertain whether this conversation was heading somewhere.
Denise looked toward the street rather than at her. “I have thought about last year more than I wanted to.”
Avery said nothing.
“I still think the original route had too many elements.”
Avery’s shoulders tightened.
“But,” Denise continued, “I should not have removed it after the board told me not to. I should not have taken the basket from Lucy. And I should not have grabbed her arm.”
The apology was so specific that Avery almost did not recognize it as one.
Denise exhaled. “I was wrong about those things.”
Avery looked at the mums. “Okay.”
That was all she could think to say.
Denise gave a brief nod. “I am not asking you to tell me it is okay.”
“It wasn’t.”
“I know.”
Another silence.
Avery finally said, “The route was not trying to replace your event.”
Denise’s mouth tightened, not in anger but in acknowledgment. “I know that now.”
“Did you think it was?”
“I thought every additional system weakened the main one. I thought if everyone created their own version of the House Crawl, the event would stop feeling like one event.”
Avery considered. “That is not completely stupid.”
Denise actually laughed. “Thank you, I think.”
“But you treated different options like they were disobedience.”
Denise looked at her. “Yes.”
Avery remembered all the sharp sentences she could have used. None seemed necessary. “We are doing fewer signs.”
“I noticed.”
“And the sponsor row still exists.”
“I noticed that too.”
Denise went back to her planter. Avery walked home feeling no sudden forgiveness, no warmth, and no desire to become friends with her. What she felt was smaller and more useful: the conflict no longer had to remain frozen at its worst moment.
She told her parents about the conversation at dinner. Daniel asked whether she believed Denise was sincere.
“I think she meant the specific apology.”
“That is a careful answer.”
Avery pointed her fork at him. “Do not get excited.”
Claire asked, “Do you forgive her?”
Avery thought. “I do not know what that is supposed to look like. I do not want to be mad every time I see her. But I still do not want her running Halloween.”
“That sounds reasonable,” Claire said.
Miles looked up from his pasta. “Can she have candy?”
Avery blinked. “What?”
“If she comes trick-or-treating.”
“She is fifty-nine.”
“Adults take candy at Mrs. Bell’s.”
Claire smiled. “If Denise comes to our house in costume, I promise we will give her candy.”
Miles nodded, satisfied that justice had been defined.