I came home from a job and the cap was gone and the hose was connected. So, I put a real lock on a hasp I mounted myself and that one lasted almost a week before I found it on the ground in two pieces. Bolt cutters. She had someone out there with bolt cutters cutting my locks off my spigot on my property to steal my water for her pool.
I then got a camera and pointed it at the corner. The footage was almost boring. Her lawn guy. Every morning before dawn, he would walk over, connect the hose, and go about his business.
And then in the evening, he would coil it up and stash it behind a little shrub on her side. He did it like it was a normal chore or something, which I assume is exactly how she described it to him. I don't think that man had any idea what the hose was actually connected to. And yeah, I want to be fair to the lawn guy.
He was just following the chore list she made for him. And then she got proactive. I started getting visits from the county. A complaint about my fence height, which is grandfathered and legal.
A complaint about my shed, which has been there since before the HOA existed. And a complaint about standing water hazards on my property, which is a septic system which is permitted, which they knew because the first two inspectors told me who filed the complaints. Neighbors can request these records, and I'm a cheap man, so I requested these records. I then went over there to talk to her about all of it one time in person like a human being, and she answered in a robe with a glass of wine, middle of the afternoon, and told me, and I'm quoting, "That water has been flowing to my property for over a year.
I've developed a claim to it. My attorney will be in touch. A claim to my well. Interesting.
Anyway, the attorney letter arrived about a week later, and it was even better than she had promised. It said something about a prescriptive easement, and how she had relied on the water for her pool, and how any interruption would constitute damages, and how I should cease tampering with the connection. My favorite part though was where it described the spigot as the shared water point Shared because she'd been stealing from it long enough that she now decided she owned it. Now, here's the thing though about being a plumber for 40 years.
You end up knowing people. My lawyer is one of my people. He has handled my permits and my occasional disagreements with inspectors since before either of us had even gray hair. I called him and read him the letter over the phone and that is when the whole thing clicked for me.