Mason Lee was halfway through drawing a yellow sun beside the community mailbox when Carol Baxter stopped so abruptly that the heels of her running shoes scraped against the concrete. "What are you doing?" she asked.
Mason looked up from his crouch. At ten years old, he had already learned that adults sometimes asked questions they had answered for themselves. Carol's eyes were on the chalk, not on him. The yellow sun was only six inches wide, tucked against the edge of the sidewalk where it would not bother anyone walking past.
"Making a marker," Mason said. Carol adjusted the visor over her brown-blond hair. Her smartwatch glowed when she folded one arm across her chest. "A marker for what?"

Mason pointed down the street. "For my sister. So she knows where she is." Carol looked at the sun again as though it had personally offended her. "Sidewalks aren't for drawing."
"It washes off." "That's not the point." Mason did not answer. He rarely argued when he did not think arguing would help, and Carol had the expression of someone who had already moved past listening. A few houses away, Lily stood beside their father near the corner, clutching the strap of a tiny purple backpack and watching for Mason's signal.
Carol followed his glance. "You children need to stop treating the neighborhood like your personal playground." A boy on a scooter slowed to look. Two girls sitting on a driveway stopped bouncing a rubber ball. Mason felt his face warm.
"Clean it," Carol said. "My dad said it was okay." "Your dad doesn't own the sidewalk."
That part, Mason knew, was technically true. The sidewalks of Pine Hollow Estates belonged to the common areas managed by the homeowners association. His father had explained that when Mason first asked whether he could use chalk outside their driveway. But David Lee had also read the neighborhood rules and found nothing that specifically prohibited washable sidewalk chalk.
Mason glanced toward his father again. David was too far away to hear the conversation clearly, but he had noticed Carol. He started walking over. Carol held up a hand before he reached them. "I'm just trying to keep things consistent, David. If we allow everyone to personalize common areas, where does it stop?"
David slowed. He was thirty-nine, wore a faded gray polo from the IT company where he worked, and had the tired patience of someone who spent most of his day helping people find buttons they insisted had disappeared from their computer screens. "It's sidewalk chalk, Carol." "Last year it was permanent marker on the south loop. The HOA paid to pressure wash that mess."
"Teenagers wrote graffiti with paint marker. Mason is drawing a sun with washable chalk." Carol's mouth tightened. "Today it's chalk. Tomorrow someone brings paint."
David looked down at the sun, then at Mason. "Finish this one, buddy. Then let's go home while the board figures out what it wants to do." Carol shook her head. "There is nothing to figure out."
But there was, and Mason knew it because his father always told him rules were supposed to be written before people were punished for breaking them. What Carol did not know was that the yellow sun was not decoration. Six-year-old Lily had once loved walking through Pine Hollow. She loved the swing set in the middle of the neighborhood, the red mailbox near the Carters' house, and the tiny koi pond behind a low black fence two streets over. But six weeks earlier, while walking to the playground with a teenage babysitter, Lily had run after a little terrier that slipped its leash. She followed the dog around a corner and into the wrong cul-de-sac.