She stopped just inside the gate and took in the scene as though she had walked into the aftermath of a party instead of a community pool. Her gaze moved from the foam ball to a pair of noodles floating beside the lane rope, from wet footprints near the chairs to one closed juice box sitting beside Denise's tote bag. Then she sighed loudly enough for nearby people to hear. "Every single time I come down here, it's chaos."
Caleb heard the comment but looked back at Sophie instead. Over the last few weeks, he had learned that answering Patricia almost always made things take longer. She had already warned him once because Sophie sat on a lounge chair before drying off, scolded Owen for a cannonball that splashed the coping, and told Lucy and Molly that leaving noodles in the water made the pool look "like a day camp." None of those incidents had become major arguments, but Caleb had noticed the pattern: Patricia never seemed relieved when children corrected something. She seemed disappointed that there was nothing left to complain about.
Patricia crossed the deck and stopped near the shallow-end steps. "No splashing," she announced. "No yelling. No horseplay. Do not crowd the stairs. Some of you are old enough to know better." Owen lowered the foam ball and looked around, confused, while Lucy and Molly moved closer together as if the rules had suddenly changed without anybody telling them.
"We're just playing," Caleb said. He kept his voice polite because Denise had taught him that adults sometimes listened better if they did not have an excuse to call a kid disrespectful. Patricia turned toward him, and even through the sunglasses he could feel the attention land directly on him. "And you are exactly old enough to stop setting the wrong example."
Owen muttered, "We didn't do anything." Patricia's head snapped toward him. "Then maybe lower your voice and prove it." She said it in the clipped tone of somebody issuing a citation, and for a few seconds all four older kids became unnaturally quiet. Sophie looked at Caleb with the first hint of uncertainty in her face.
Denise closed her book. "They're not doing anything dangerous." Patricia gave her a thin smile. "That depends on what standard you use." Denise glanced at the rules posted beside the gate. "The posted rules, I assume."
The smile disappeared. "The posted rules are the minimum," Patricia said. "Common sense is supposed to do the rest." Denise held her gaze for a moment, then leaned back in the chair. "Okay. Then if they break an actual rule, let me know." Patricia walked away, but the set of her shoulders said the conversation had not ended in her mind.