I did ask. At the next board meeting, held in the multipurpose room of a church down the road, I requested copies of the minutes authorizing the new parking restrictions. Beverly sat at the head of a folding table with a wooden nameplate in front of her. Beside her were the treasurer, a tired accountant named Carol Henderson, and the secretary, a middle-school teacher named Rosa Alvarez. Beverly announced that my presence was evidence of growing disorder among newer residents. I answered that I was not new to my father's home and wanted to make sure everyone followed the same rules.
"We have discretion to interpret our covenants," she said.
"Then you can show me where the board voted to create this interpretation," I replied.
Carol lowered her eyes to a stack of papers. Rosa opened her notebook and asked Beverly whether she had a motion to record. For a moment the room was completely quiet. Beverly finally said the discussion would be postponed until she had consulted counsel. Two weeks later, I received a notice alleging that my presence at the meeting had been disruptive. Dad pinned it to the refrigerator under a magnet shaped like a smiling tomato.
By June, I had begun to understand how deeply the dispute was wearing on him. His cardiologist wanted him to walk every afternoon, gradually increasing the distance. The first time we made it to Minh's mailbox and back, Dad insisted on taking a photograph to send Sophie. But whenever Beverly's golf cart appeared, he grew tense and asked to go inside. Once I found him sitting at the kitchen table with a fine notice open before him, rubbing the center of his chest. The notice was for an unauthorized yellow garden hose, bought because it was easier for him to see against the grass. I took it away and told him I would handle things, but he looked at me as if that promise worried him even more.
"I didn't raise you to spend your days fighting an unhappy woman," he said.
"You raised me not to let somebody bully you."
"There's a difference between keeping your dignity and feeding a quarrel. Learn it sooner than I did."
There were parts of my father's life I knew only in outlines. He had worked as a lawyer, then as a judge, and retired years before my mother died. He spoke warmly of clerks and bailiffs, seldom of decisions, and almost never of the people who appeared before him. To me he was the man who burned pancakes when I was nine and stayed awake beside my bed when I had pneumonia. I knew he could be stubborn. I did not know why he kept a sealed brown envelope labeled CEDAR HOLLOW—FOUNDING DOCUMENTS in a drawer he rarely opened.
The first time I noticed it, I was looking for the manual to the basement pump. Dad stood in the doorway, saw the envelope in my hand, and asked me to put it back. I started to tease him about secret buried treasure, but his expression stopped me. "Nothing you need to worry about," he said. Then he added, more softly, "Some rules were written after people learned what happens when there aren't any." I assumed he meant his years on the bench. I replaced the envelope and forgot about it, or tried to.
Summer brought new frustrations. A delivery driver reported that Beverly had ordered him not to use the service turnaround even while unloading oxygen supplies. A visiting home-care nurse was stopped at the entrance and made to explain whom she intended to see. Dad's physician adjusted a medication after he complained of dizziness, and the nurse emphasized