"Rennick objected. The judge allowed it. Lyle Creel held up his left hand. Five fingers, all of them whole. "
Asa Vance lost two fingers off that hand to a freight train in Grand Island in '74,"Delia said. " Everybody at Dry Fork knew it. He used to charge men a nickel to look at it. "Creel said she was mistaken.
He said it twice. He said it was a different hand, and then he said he had never been in Grand Island, and the room began to turn, and Rennick said something about a woman's faulty memory after 11 years. That was when the church doors opened at the back. Caleb Calder came up the aisle with road dust to the knees and 6 days of beard, and behind him came a Laramie deputy named Oaks with a satchel.
He laid three things on the judge's table. The register of the Dry Fork Stage Station, 1874, in which Asa Vance had signed his name with an X and the station master had written beside it, "Cannot hold pen, hand crippled. "The burial record of the county in Nebraska, dated September 8th, 1875, "Asa Vance, age 31."And Deputy Oaks, who was sworn, and who looked at the man standing there and said he knew him well. His name was Lyle Creel.
He had sworn a false affidavit in a Nebraska land case 2 years earlier and had been paid $80 to do it. Creel sat down slowly. Then, because perjury in front of a circuit judge is a different animal than lying to a notary, he said who had paid him. " Ninety dollars in Denver, paid by the young gentleman sitting in the second pew.
"Ellis Teague did not look at his mother. Rennick went to his second paper. He had to. He read Dr. Pell's affidavit out loud, "Unsound mind, disordered nerves, unfit for the keeping of children.
"And called the doctor to swear to it. Pell swore. He said he had examined Mrs. Calder in the autumn and had formed his opinion then. In the fourth pew, Hannah Mabry stood up.
The preacher's wife had been one of the four women at that tea. She had sat and looked at her lap while a woman's name was taken from her. Now she came up the aisle with a cloth bundle in both hands and set it on the judge's table. " Three days before that still room burned," she said, "Mrs. Calder brought this to the church poor box and asked me to keep it where nobody could get at it.
She told me what it was. I didn't want to believe her. I kept it anyway. "Judge Sibley opened the cloth.