"You've seen that shoe before," Caleb said.
She stood too quickly. "Lots of shoes break."
"Not in the same corner."
Clara climbed back onto her horse. "Please don't ask me yet."
Caleb wanted to. Instead he nodded and rode beside her in silence. That night someone fired a single rifle shot from the dark beyond the horse corral. The bullet buried itself in the porch post six inches from where Caleb had been standing. Clara came running from the house barefoot, and the moment she saw the splintered wood, she stopped as if she had been struck.
The next morning she asked Caleb to saddle two horses before sunrise. They rode north into the foothills to an abandoned line shack Caleb used during winter roundups. Once inside, Clara shut the door and removed her gloves. Scars crossed both wrists, pale ridges that looked like old rope burns. Then, after several minutes of silence, she reached up and unpinned the veil.
The left side of her face was not ruined, as the broker had implied. A narrow scar began near her temple, passed across her cheek, and disappeared beneath the collar of her dress. It had healed silver-white except for one darker line near the jaw where letters had been cut into the skin. Caleb leaned closer only when she nodded permission. The carved name read ELI VALE.
Caleb froze. His father had spoken that name exactly once, eighteen years earlier, after returning from a cattle drive with blood on his coat and refusing to explain where it came from. Eli Vale had been the leader of the Ash Riders, an outlaw band that burned ranches, robbed payroll wagons, and disappeared into mountain country before federal marshals could close in. Officially, Vale had died during a shootout near Piedra Pass in 1871. Unofficially, half the old ranchers in the county believed he had escaped.
"Who did this to you?" Caleb asked.
Clara's fingers tightened around the veil. "Eli Vale's brother."
Caleb stared at the name again. "Why carve Eli's name?"
"Because Silas Vale wanted everyone who found me to think I belonged to Eli's bloodline." Her eyes lifted to Caleb's. "And because, in a way, I do. Eli Vale was my father."
For several seconds Caleb heard only wind scraping dry grass against the shack. Clara told him her mother, Miriam Bell, had worked as a laundress in a mining camp where she met Eli before his outlaw reputation hardened into legend. Miriam left him after learning the Ash Riders had begun killing witnesses. Months later she discovered she was pregnant, changed her surname, and spent years moving from town to town while Eli's younger brother Silas searched for them.
Eli died before he ever found Miriam again, but Silas did not. He believed Eli had hidden a ledger listing cattle brands, stolen land deeds, corrupt deputies, and the locations of money buried from six robberies. Silas became convinced Miriam had the ledger and that Clara, as Eli's daughter, knew where it was. When Clara was seventeen, Silas's men abducted her mother and held them for nearly a week in a logging camp.