They were provided by an anonymous source with no chain of custody. We have no way to verify they're genuine. The handwriting analysis, Jessica started, is based on documents that could have been forged. We have our own handwriting expert who will testify that the signatures are inconsistent with Mr. Sloan's known writing samples. Judge Chu made a note.
We'll hear from both experts. Mr. Sloan, do you wish to testify? Conrad stood. He looked older than he had in the deposition, more tired, but his voice was still strong when he spoke. Your honor, I've spent 43 years at Vale Automotive.
I've made thousands of decisions, many of them difficult, all of them with the company's best interests and the welfare of our employees in mind. Mr. Pierce was a talented engineer who made valuable contributions to the VX-7 design, but he was also inflexible, unable to accept that engineering is about balancing competing priorities, safety, cost, timeline, manufacturability. When we couldn't meet every specification he insisted on, he took it personally. And when we had to let him go for performance issues, he began a decade-long campaign to destroy the company that had given him his start. Nolan started to stand, but Jessica put a hand on his arm.
Wait. The payment records Ms. Chen presented, " Conrad continued, "are sophisticated forgeries created to support Mr. Pierce's narrative. I never paid to suppress evidence. I never authorized payments to silence employees. These documents are fabrications, and we will prove that conclusively. "
Judge Chu looked at the payment records, then at Conrad. " Mr. Sloan, setting aside the authenticity question for a moment, are you denying that you had any knowledge of the VX-7 defect prior to the recent recalls? " " I'm saying that we had reports of potential issues, as we do with every engine platform. Some engineers thought the alloy composition needed adjustment. Others believed it was within acceptable parameters.
We ran additional tests, consulted external experts, and made a judgment call based on the best available data. And the accelerated production timeline? Was necessary to meet contractual obligations. We had committed to delivery dates. Failing to meet those dates would have cost us hundreds of millions in penalties, and potentially bankrupted the company.
So, you chose to meet the timeline rather than address the safety concerns. We chose to proceed with production while continuing to monitor and test. It was a calculated risk based on incomplete data. In hindsight, we should have delayed production, but at the time, with the information we had, it seemed like the right decision. " Judge Chu was quiet for a moment.
Then she said, "Mr. Sloan, I've been a judge for 22 years. I've heard a lot of testimony from a lot of people trying to justify questionable decisions. And I have to say you're very good at making negligence sound like reasonable business judgment. Your Honor, I'm simply explaining "I know what you're explaining, and if this were just a business dispute, your explanation might be sufficient. But we're talking about hundreds of deaths.
And the payment records, authentic or not, suggest a pattern of concealment that goes well beyond honest disagreement about engineering priorities. Conrad's attorney stood again. Your honor, we'd like to call a witness who can speak to Mr. Pierce's credibility and motivations. Who's the witness? Michael Torres.
He's a private investigator who was hired by Mr. Pierce last year to Objection, Jessica said sharply. We've had no notice of this witness. His name doesn't appear anywhere in the defendant's filings. We disclosed him in Monday's emergency motion, which was filed less than 48 hours ago in violation of discovery rules. Judge Chu held up a hand.
Enough. Mr. Torres, are you present? A man stood from the gallery. Nolan recognized him. Not Torres the security guard, but someone else.