Ethan had not attended the meeting. He was at his own shop replacing a failed wheel bearing on a family sedan, and he preferred it that way. Owen called afterward and described what Vivian had said. Ethan listened, then asked whether the technicians would be given sufficient time and resources to follow the new procedures. Owen laughed. "You don't let anybody enjoy a moment, do you?" he asked. Ethan replied that moments were easy; the next six months would show whether the apology meant anything. Owen said the pilot budget had been approved, the training schedule was being developed, and Vivian had already removed the incentive that rewarded managers solely for closing the highest number of jobs. Ethan told him that was a beginning.
On the first day of the pilot, Ethan returned to Cross Performance wearing the same patched coveralls. Some employees expected him to arrive in a new uniform or trade his toolbox for company equipment. He did neither. He had brought a notebook containing the first set of case review questions, and he asked each technician to identify one recurring complaint that had proved difficult to resolve. The room was reluctant. Peter eventually described a luxury sedan that had returned twice with an intermittent warning. Another technician mentioned a performance coupe that hesitated during acceleration. Ethan did not tell them what was wrong with either vehicle. He asked what had been observed during the fault, what had been tested, and what remained unknown. The exercise made several people uncomfortable because it exposed gaps they had previously learned to overlook.
The sedan case became the first real test of the program. Its previous repair orders listed a replaced battery, a replaced control module, and two short road tests. The customer still reported intermittent electrical warnings after rainy nights. Ethan assigned Peter and a senior technician to review the complaint and reproduce the condition under approved procedures. The evidence eventually pointed to moisture entering a poorly sealed connector in a body harness. The repair cost far less than another module and required documenting the water entry path so the fault would not return. Peter photographed the damaged seal, recorded the measurements, and wrote a clear explanation for the service adviser. When the customer collected the car, she understood why the previous repairs had not solved her problem. She was not pleased about the wasted time, but she appreciated a report that told her the truth.
Vivian reviewed the case later that week. The repair had taken longer than the old target, yet its parts cost was lower and the evidence stronger. She asked the service manager whether the customer was satisfied. He said the customer wanted a written assurance that the repair had been verified and would continue to watch the car carefully. Vivian said that was reasonable. She then asked what the earlier records had failed to capture. Peter explained that nobody had established the conditions under which the warning appeared. They had replaced components associated with the code rather than reproducing the fault. Vivian listened without interrupting. Ethan noticed and did not comment. A manager who could listen was harder to celebrate than a CEO who made a dramatic promise, but more useful in the long run.