“Fix My Porsche and I'll Marry You,” the CEO Joked — Then the Single Dad Recognized a Hidden Mark

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The Heinrich provenance alone added probably $400,000 to the value because of how few of his personal restorations existed. The car had been deliberately devalued on the firm's books by approximately $1 million. I sat with that for a long time. Then, I went to bed. The next morning, I called James Holloway.

James was an attorney I had met through Dr. Caldwell, the Mercedes owner. He practiced commercial litigation in Stamford with a small firm that handled mostly business disputes and estate matters. I had used him once 2 years ago to draft the operating agreement for the shop. He was 52, careful, and had the kind of practical mind that did not waste motion on things that didn't matter. I told him I needed 30 minutes of his time, and that I would pay his consultation rate.

He asked me what it was about. I told him I'd rather explain in person. He had an opening at 4:00 that afternoon. I took it. I drove to his office on Atlantic Street in Stamford at 3:50.

I brought a printout of the SEC filing, my photographs from the garage, the auction comparable for 1973 Carrera RS Lightweight with verified provenance, and a brief one-page summary of what I had observed. James read everything without speaking. It took him about 12 minutes. When he was done, he looked up. You're saying someone has been inside this engine bay and made changes specifically designed to defeat authentication of the car's restoration history.

Yes. And the car is currently valued on the firm's books at less than a quarter of its actual market value. Yes. And the person who would have authority to do both of those things is the same person. Preston Vance.

I don't know for certain. But the timing fits and he's the only person at the firm who would have the kind of access to make those changes and the motive to depress the valuation. What's the motive? He's preparing to acquire it. Or already has on paper through some related party transaction that we'd need to see the firm's internal records to identify.

If he can get the car titled to himself or to a controlled entity at the depressed valuation and then sell it for actual market value, he pockets the difference. About a million dollars. And if Vivian doesn't know what the car actually is, she has no reason to question the valuation. James leaned back in his chair. You know what you're describing is a federal crime.

Yes. Wire fraud at minimum. Likely embezzlement and breach of fiduciary duty depending on the specific structure. Yes. He was quiet for a moment.

Why are you here, Ethan? Why not just finish the car and walk away? Because she didn't know what she was looking at when she asked me to look at it. And because the man who built that engine taught me something about how this work is supposed to be done. And because if I walk away, she loses the car and probably much more than the car.

News in the same category

“Fix My Porsche and I'll Marry You,” the CEO Joked — Then the Single Dad Recognized a Hidden Mark

15 Part