criticizing the deputy's driving. In the second she listed opening the car door, attempting to strike the deputy, possessing a weapon, and threatening physical harm. Caleb looked at the page for a long time. He said the radio host might not care about the distinctions. Martha replied that she cared enough for both of them.
The exercise became useful when Elena asked Martha to prepare for a deposition. Attorneys would likely ask about her prior interactions with police, her emotional state, and the exact position of her hands when she approached the vehicle. Martha had never been cross-examined, and she imagined it as a procedure designed to make her forget simple facts. Elena explained that a witness could ask to have a question repeated, answer only what she knew, and say honestly when she did not remember. Martha practiced with Caleb at home. He pretended to be aggressive, and she told him he sounded like an actor in a bad courtroom show.
They began again more seriously. Caleb asked whether she had been angry when she approached the deputy. Martha answered yes. He asked whether she had wanted to frighten him. She said no, she had wanted him to understand that his driving had frightened her. Caleb asked how he could know the difference between her intention and the deputy's reaction. She thought before answering. "He couldn't know everything immediately," she said. "But he could ask, and he could look at what I actually did." Caleb wrote down the sentence and told her it was clearer than anything she had said on the day of the arrest.
The preparation brought them closer, but it also exposed how much Martha had lost trust in ordinary encounters. She grew uneasy when a city employee knocked on her door to inspect a water meter. She asked him for identification twice, then felt embarrassed when he remained patient. One evening she called Caleb because a police car had parked near her block for twenty minutes. Caleb drove over before realizing the officer was responding to a medical call down the street. Martha apologized for alarming him. Caleb said she did not have to apologize for being shaken, but they should find a way to keep fear from directing every decision.
Elena suggested a counselor experienced with the aftermath of frightening public encounters. Martha resisted because she had been raised to treat distress as something resolved by usefulness, prayer, or a brisk walk. She had spent decades helping other people without asking for much herself. It seemed extravagant to pay someone to discuss a day she wished to forget. Then she realized that she was becoming exhausted by the effort not to remember it. She agreed to an appointment.