Female Cop Arrested the Man Who Called 911 — Then Surveillance Footage Changed Everything

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Was she saying anything to him about that? I I don't remember. Um, I don't I don't probably that I remember. Okay. Um, I don't know.

That's At what point did the gun become involved? Um, I'm not really sure. It was after that. But but Well, how did How did he know that you were armed? Um, I'm not sure.

I mean, you told that other officer that you put your hands up like this, so that my gun was under a Um, I'm I'm not completely sure, to be honest with you. I know it didn't come out of the holster or anything like that. No, I didn't say it came out, but how was he able to know that you were armed? Because he called us, he said that you were armed. So, how did he know that?

I don't know. I mean, if I lift my shirt up, you could see it. Okay. So, did you want him to see that you were armed? Did you tell him you were armed?

Um, I don't know. I don't think so. No. On May 12th, 3 days later, Benedetto Salvio was charged with improper exhibition of a dangerous weapon. He eventually entered a pretrial diversion program, completed anger management and gun safety classes.

The charge was then dismissed. And Officer Guerrero, on August 25th, 2023, Chief Clint Shannon announced that Officer Bethany Guerrero had been terminated. 19 years on the force, making over $100,000 a year. The Internal Affairs investigation found she had violated multiple department policies in her conduct toward Ryan Gold. Which leads to a critical question of what happened here.

Was what happened with Ryan Gold legal? Well, first, when Gold reached into his pocket for his phone, Guerrero later admitted she believed he was reaching for a weapon. Under Heien v. North Carolina, a reasonable mistake of fact by a police officer can still justify a stop or an encounter. But reasonable is the keyword, and the security camera helped us define that this was really not very reasonable. But what about the force Officer Guerrero chose to use against Ryan Gold?

In order for Officer Guerrero to use the force that she used, and to justify what she did here, she's got to under U. S. v. Acosta be able to show an objective reasonable belief that he was dangerous, potentially dangerous to her and the other officers. But you just looked at the footage. Did that look objectively reasonable to you? I mean, I doesn't seem to me that it was anything like how she described it.

And he did not seem to pose a real threat to her or any of the other officers. And then there's what happened to the other officers on scene. They watched Guerrero draw her weapon and arrest a man who called 911 for help. Not a single one of them stopped it. Not one of them was disciplined for it either, which brings us to the ultimate questions.

Was the actions of Ryan Gold and Officer Guerrero lawful or awful? Let's start with Officer Bethany Guerrero. She pointed her firearm at an unarmed man who was backing away. She arrested the person who called 911, turned off her body cam for the remainder of the encounter, and gave an account that the surveillance footage clearly contradicted. 19 years on the job, and she was fired.

It was awful. What about Ryan Gold? He called 911 when threatened. He waited where he was told. He challenged every unlawful action on camera.

He demanded accountability from the moment the cuffs went on. And then he was released before he was even processed, and the footage did what he couldn't. It told the truth. So, for Ryan Gold, lawful. But, if there's one thing he could have done different, is he's got to be aware anytime you grab or put your hands in your pockets or reach for anything, get ready for cops to use it as a pretext to draw down on you claiming their officer safety is at risk.

And what about the supervisor who was quick to actually review the surveillance video footage? I've got to tell you, I was proud of his actions. He took the time to immediately look and see, did Officer Guerrero tell the truth?

Did it really go down that way? And the moment he realized it didn't go down that way, he turned around, called the jail, had him released. I'll say right out of the gate, this officer acted lawful.

News in the same category

Female Cop Arrested the Man Who Called 911 — Then Surveillance Footage Changed Everything

5 Part