The outside council Thomas had mentioned was there too, a woman named Patricia Hris from a white shoe law firm that specialized in corporate litigation. Richard Hollstrom and Peter Yates sat together on one side of the table, both looking grim. Her father sat at the head, his expression unreadable. Vanessa took her seat and waited. At exactly 8:00, the board chairman, a semi-retired investment banker named Gerald Morrison, called the meeting to order.
We're here to discuss yesterday's decision to terminate the garrison merger, he began. Vanessa, we'd like you to walk us through your reasoning. She'd prepared for this, spent the sleepless hours between 3 and 6:00 a. m. organizing her thoughts, building her case. She pulled up the contract analysis Ethan had provided and walked the board through every provision, every cross reference, every subtle mechanism that would have transferred control. It took 40 minutes.
When she finished, the room was silent. Patricia Hendrickx spoke first. I've reviewed these provisions as well, and I have to say, this is sophisticated work, the kind of structure you'd only build if you specifically intended to create a delayed control transfer. Or Richard Hollstrom cut in, the kind of language that looks suspicious if you're predisposed to see threats everywhere. Patricia shook her head.
Mr. Holstrm, I've been doing corporate law for 23 years. This isn't standard language. This is deliberate architecture. Based on what evidence? Garrison hasn't done anything to suggest hostile intent.
We're condemning them based on theoretical possibilities. Theoretical possibilities that would have cost us the company, Vanessa said. Or theoretical possibilities that gave you an excuse to back out of a deal you were too scared to close. The accusation hung in the air. Gerald Morrison cleared his throat.
Let's stay focused on the facts. Patricia, in your professional opinion, did these contract provisions represent a genuine threat to Sterling's independence? Yes. If implemented as written, control would have shifted to Garrison's parent company between months 15 and 20 post merger. The structure is textbook acquisition disguised as partnership.
And could we have negotiated changes to these provisions? Possibly. But given how deeply embedded they are across multiple sections, I suspect Garrison would have either refused or simply restructured the same mechanisms differently. This wasn't accidental language. This was intentional.
Peter Yates leaned forward. So, we're saying Garrison deliberately tried to trap us. I'm saying the contract was structured in a way that would benefit them significantly more than us. And that benefit was hidden well enough that most legal teams would miss it. Most legal teams did miss it, Robert Sterling said, speaking for the first time, including ours.
The only reason we caught it was because Vanessa brought in an outside consultant at the last minute. Who is this consultant? Gerald asked. Ethan Callaway, Vanessa said. Former M&A specialist.