Fake HOA Cops Slammed Me to the Ground — Then Three Black SUVs Pulled Into My Street

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Its assets were seized. The 8,000 square feet of office space it had occupied in Garner became the new headquarters of the Wake County Sheriff's Auxiliary Volunteer Program. The Hartford Pines HOA was placed under court-ordered receivership. A new board was elected the following spring.

Hollis Penberthy served as president for one term, refused to sit a second, and handed the gavel to Lorraine Reinhardt, Tyler's mother, whose first official act was to fire the management company and rewrite the CC&Rs from 44 pages to nine. She tore down the gates at the entrance to the subdivision the same week. I went back to work at the Charlotte Field Office. Tessa got a commendation.

Hollis got a thank-you letter signed by the director. Sheriff Carmody got himself another 5-year term and a regional law enforcement award. But, the part of this story that mattered most happened the following October. On a warm Saturday afternoon, half the neighborhood gathered in our backyard for the first annual Hartford Pines Citizens Education Day.

Sheriff Carmody brought two deputies and a folding table full of brochures. A retired Wake County Superior Court judge gave a 40-minute talk in our gazebo on what private security companies can and cannot legally do. A volunteer from the ACLU walked teenagers through their rights during a stop. Hollis taught a 30-minute crash course on how to read your CC&Rs without getting hosed.

Tyler Reinhardt, now 17 and an inch taller, a full year quieter, gave the closing remarks. He read for 6 minutes in a steady voice from a sheet of yellow legal paper Hollis had helped him draft. He talked about what it had felt like to be in the back of that Tahoe. He talked about the silence afterward.

He talked about the moment he had decided to tell the truth in front of a grand jury, and how that decision had felt larger than he was. He ended his speech with one sentence. " My mom and I aren't going anywhere, and neither is anyone else on this street." The crowd stood.

That afternoon, I planted a small dogwood tree at the back of our property in memory of my old partner, Charlie Eldridge, who'd been killed 5 years earlier in a botched takedown of a sovereign citizen militia in Mineral Wells, West Virginia. Charlie had spent his whole career chasing fake cops. He never got to see one go down on a federal indictment. I told Caroline that night on the porch that the dogwood was for him.

She said, "He'd be proud of you, Mason." I said, "He'd be proud of all of us." We sat on the porch swing for a long time, watching the cicadas hum in the loblollies, the smell of pine sap on the air, the long Carolina evening settling around us like a quilt. Cooper came out around 9:00 in his sock feet with a mug of cocoa.

He sat down between us. He didn't say anything. He didn't have to. The cul-de-sac was quiet.

The gates were gone. The fake cops were in federal prison. The neighborhood I had wanted Caroline to have was finally the neighborhood we lived in. The dogwood tree took root that fall.

By the following May, it bloomed white as paper. A volunteer attorney from the Wake County Bar drove up from Raleigh that same spring and helped Lorraine Reinhardt set up a small fund, the Sycamore Civil Rights Project, that pays for camera systems, doorbell recorders, and one free hour of legal review for any homeowner in the county who suspects their HOA is operating outside the law. In its first 8 months, the fund equipped 41 houses across three subdivisions and helped two boards get voted out clean. The corkboard above our kitchen counter has been getting fuller every month since.

News in the same category

Fake HOA Cops Slammed Me to the Ground — Then Three Black SUVs Pulled Into My Street

15 Part