“Everyone Thought He’d Choose the Beautiful Sister — Then He Asked for the Girl Who Worked in the Barn

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Horace emerged from the house furious and demanded to know why Ella had returned. She stood beside the injured watchman, her palm bleeding where a splinter had reopened the old scar, and said she had come because people could have been killed. Adelaide rushed to Daniel, crying that he had risked his life for their family. Daniel gently stepped away and asked whether she had checked on the watchman. Adelaide stared at him, then turned toward the house without answering.

Daniel cleaned Ella's hand in the stable while the sheriff took statements. She tried to insist that the cut was nothing, but he reminded her that an injury did not become smaller because she refused to acknowledge it. His fingers were careful around the old scar. Ella watched him knot the bandage and wondered when she had begun to trust this man enough to let him see her in pain. She was frightened by the answer, and more frightened that he might already know.

The following morning, Rusk told the sheriff he had been paid by a ranch broker named Leonard Pike to drive Marrow cattle toward the old creek crossing. Pike had recently purchased options on several small farms downstream and had been lobbying for exclusive control of the ditch. Horace denied any connection to the raid, and no witness could place him with Rusk. Yet the discovery forced the county to examine the water dispute more closely, and the sheriff advised both ranchers to keep armed guards at night until the matter was settled.

Ella remembered Pike visiting her father's office the previous summer. She also remembered her grandfather's trunk and an old phrase her mother used when discussing family papers: the blue book tells the truth. She returned to the Marrow house with Ruth as a witness and asked Horace for her mother's personal belongings, which the family had never divided. Horace tried to refuse, but Adelaide, irritated by the argument, ordered a servant to fetch the trunk from the attic. Ella found her mother's letters, a small blue notebook, and several photographs beneath a folded shawl.

The blue notebook was not a deed. It was a record of payments, repairs, and water measurements made by her grandfather, Thomas Marrow, during the years he and Nathan Rowan maintained the ditch together. Tucked inside the back cover was a letter signed by both men acknowledging their shared right to draw water and agreeing that neither family could block the other without mutual consent. The signatures matched surviving letters, and the document bore the witness mark of a territorial clerk whose name appeared in county records. Ella carried it to the lawyer before telling Daniel what she had found.

News in the same category

“Everyone Thought He’d Choose the Beautiful Sister — Then He Asked for the Girl Who Worked in the Barn

15 Part