Everyone in Town Saw Her Bruises — Then One Stranger Asked, “Who Did This to You?”

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He looked around at the gathered street, the whole town watching from porches and doorways, pretending not to listen. We'll do this at the sheriff's office. Formal on the record, nobody talking over anybody else. Martha stepped forward from the edge of the crowd, her composure perfectly intact, her voice carrying warm and reasonable across the street.

Marshall Crowe, I want you to know I welcome this inquiry fully. I have nothing to hide and I'll answer any question you care to put to me. I only ask that you consider the source of these accusations a troubled girl with a history of falsehoods and a stranger who's been in town less than a week. I consider every source, ma'am.

That's my whole job. Crow's tone gave nothing away. Sheriff, let's get started. Miss Whitaker, if you'll come with me.

The sheriff's office was small, close-lit by a single lamp that threw long shadows against the walls, and Grace sat across the desk from Marshall Crowe with her hands folded tight in her lap to keep them from shaking. " Take your time," Crowe said. " Start wherever feels right to you." Grace started with the numbers because numbers were the one thing in her whole life Martha had never managed to make her doubt.

She recited the ledger entries she'd memorized, dates, amounts, the pattern of church donations returning as loan repayments, the ranch income figures that fell short of what her father's land should have produced year over year. Crow wrote steadily, his face giving nothing away, but Grace noticed his pen slow, then stop entirely when she reached the entry about the Henderson debt. You're telling me you memorized specific dollar figures, specific dates after a single reading of a ledger you had maybe 10, 15 minutes alone with? Yes, sir.

Grace met his eyes steady despite the shake in her hands. My father taught me figures before he died. Marshall taught me to hold columns in my head the way some folks hold hymns. I know it sounds strange, a girl claiming a memory like that, but you can check it against Mrs. Hail's own copied records kept separate from me for 8 years with no way for either of us to coordinate a story.

If our numbers match without either of us knowing what the other would say, that's not coincidence, sir. That's truth. Crow studied her a long moment, something shifting behind his careful, professional expression. And the cellar.

Tell me about the cellar. Grace's composure wavered for the first time. She looked down at her hands, and when she spoke again, her voice had dropped low, halting. She locked me down there whenever I displeased her.

Broken dishes, spilled milk. Once for 3 days after she caught me writing a letter to my aunt in Abalene, asking for help. She looked up, forced herself to hold his gaze even as her eyes filled. The last time was 4 days ago, sir, for looking in her ledger.

News in the same category

Everyone in Town Saw Her Bruises — Then One Stranger Asked, “Who Did This to You?”

50 Part