Harold remembered the complaints. He remembered supervisors telling workers not to discuss them, and he remembered a rumor that safety problems had been exaggerated to justify removing Cole Recovery from one mill's work. He had no document proving who started the rumor, and he was careful not to pretend otherwise. But he recalled the way workers talked about Nathaniel. "He was good at his job," Harold said. "Some people couldn't stand that he was good at his job and didn't need their permission to know it. That's what I remember."
Denise asked whether anyone had defended him. Harold looked down at his hands. "Not loudly enough," he said. He described a meeting at which a manager questioned Nathaniel's equipment records despite having approved them weeks earlier. Harold had stayed silent, afraid of losing his own job. He apologized to Denise for that silence, though she told him she had not come to ask for an apology. He insisted anyway. Sometimes an apology took fifty years to find its proper address.
Another lead came from a county clerk who located microfilmed business records. The files confirmed the dates of the property transfer and showed that one of Nathaniel's former clients had obtained a new contract with Russell Vane's company shortly after suspending Cole Recovery. That fact alone did not prove collusion, but it supported the chronology in Nathaniel's letter. Isaiah ordered certified copies and added them to the file. Each document made the story more precise and, in some ways, more painful. He could see the company shrinking not as a dramatic collapse but as a series of decisions made in offices where his grandfather had little influence.
The work became a strain on Isaiah's business. He spent evenings reading correspondence after long days in the shop and missed one assignment for his college course. Gloria warned him that the history could consume all the time Nathaniel had wanted him to use building a future. Isaiah knew she was right. He began limiting research to two evenings a week and asked Denise to help with calls when her schedule allowed. That adjustment was harder than any technical calculation. He wanted to keep digging until every question had an answer, but some questions might never have one.
One Sunday he visited Paul Whitaker, who had invited him to lunch after hearing about the old documents. Paul's wife served stew, and the three of them ate in a kitchen with muddy boots lined neatly beside the door. Paul remembered hearing Nathaniel's name from his father, who had worked in the mills. He had been too young to know what happened in 1972, but he understood how quietly a business could be pushed out when clients stopped returning calls. He told Isaiah that publishing the evidence might not make everyone comfortable. "Some folks around here have spent a long time believing their fathers were fair men," he said. "They may not enjoy finding out how the business was done."