What was happening on Route 12 was by any measure extraordinary. But what was happening inside Victor Grayson's Wednesday afternoon was something else entirely, and it was moving faster than he knew. Sarah Carter made seven calls between noon and 2:00. Three of them were to attorneys. One was to a private investigator who had been documenting Victor's property acquisitions for the past six weeks.
One was to a former county employee who had left the assessor's office 8 months earlier and who when Sarah explained that she was looking into the reassessment process for the Parker property went very quiet and then said in a careful voice, "I've been waiting for someone to call about that." Her name was Margaret Olsen. She was 58, had worked in the county assessor's office for 19 years, and had resigned without explanation the previous February. She met Sarah at a coffee shop in the next town over, 40 minutes from Millersburg at 2:30 Wednesday afternoon. She brought a folder.
Sarah opened the folder and read for 6 minutes without speaking. When she looked up, her face was composed, but something behind her eyes was moving fast. "You kept copies," Sarah said. "I kept copies," Margaret said. "Because I knew that if I left without taking them, there would be nothing left to find later.
The originals were adjusted within a week of my resignation. She paused. I want you to understand what you're looking at. The reassessment on the Parker property was not calculated by the standard formula. It was set by a number that was provided to our office by an outside party.
That outside party is documented in the internal correspondence you're holding. Victor Grayson. Sarah said his attorney technically, but yes. Margaret looked at her steadily. I refused to sign off on it.
I was told my position was being restructured. I resigned the following Monday. She folded her hands on the table. I have wanted to do something with this information for 8 months. I didn't know what.
I didn't know who to bring it to. I was scared. She met Sarah's eyes. I'm not scared anymore. Sarah reached across the table and put her hand briefly on Margaret's.
You're not alone in this anymore either, she said. She drove back to Millersburg with the folder on the passenger seat and made two more calls. The second of those calls was to a contact at the FBI field office in Billings, a woman named Agent Torres, whom Sarah had worked with on a corruption case 3 years earlier. She did not have to explain much. She gave Torres the key facts developer county officials manufactured legal jeopardy documented evidence, probable arson.