“You know what.”
He looked up.
“Because a whole town was pretending something wrong had become ordinary.”
“That’s not a reason to spend three wolf pelts.”
“They were good pelts.”
Despite herself, Clara almost smiled.
Then the smile vanished. “What do you want from me?”
“Nothing.”
“No man pays for nothing.”
“I didn’t pay for you.”
“You threw down a price.”
“I paid for the argument to end.”
Clara gripped the cup tighter.
Elias stood.
“My father used to say there are men who charge money for things they never owned. Silas Crane looked like one of them.”
The name made her flinch.
Elias noticed, but he did not press.
They walked another mile before a horse screamed somewhere above the trail.
Clara froze.
The sound came again—high, frantic, familiar.
She dropped the tin cup.
“Wait.”
Elias turned.
Clara’s hands flew to the cord beneath the canvas sack. She had refused to remove it in town because she would not let those men have the satisfaction of seeing her face after they had spent weeks turning it into a story. Now she pulled the knot loose and tore the sack away.
Cold struck her cheeks.
Elias stared.
Clara’s right side was strikingly beautiful: gray-green eye, dark lashes, high cheekbone, thick chestnut hair braided down her back. The left side carried a web of pale scars from temple to collarbone, old burns that had healed unevenly but cleanly. Yet it was not the scars that stopped him.
It was the small shape visible at the base of her neck where one scar curved around a natural birthmark.
A broken star.
He had seen it before.
A black gelding burst between the pines.
The horse skidded in the snow, snorting white breath. A crescent of silver hair marked its brow, and branded into the leather strap around its neck was the same broken-star symbol.
Clara made a sound so small Elias almost missed it.
“Orion.”
The horse lowered its head.
She stepped forward.
The animal pressed its forehead against her chest.
Clara wrapped both arms around its face and began to cry without making a sound.
Elias looked from the horse to the birthmark, then back again.
“Where did you get him?”
“I didn’t.” Clara wiped her face. “He belonged to my mother.”
Elias went still.
“What was her name?”
Clara hesitated.
“Adeline Vale.”
Snow whispered through the trees.
Elias knew that name.
Everyone who had lived in Black Pine County twenty years earlier knew it.
The Vale family had owned the Red Cedar Ranch, three thousand acres stretching along the north river and into the mineral flats where silver had later been found. Adeline Vale had disappeared after accusing several businessmen of forging water rights and land transfers. Her husband died the same year. Their only child was said to have perished in a wagon fire.
Elias looked at Clara.
“How old were you when your mother disappeared?”
“Six.”
His stomach tightened.
The dates matched.
Clara watched his face.
“You know something.”
“I know the story they told.”
“And?”
“I don’t think it was true.”