Malcolm had first met Florence at a church basement where she served lemonade in paper cups. She was seventy-two, had a habit of folding every napkin into a neat square, and had lived in the river district for forty-six years. She told him about the tow truck, the missing traffic camera footage, and the officer who laughed when she asked for an incident report. She did not know Malcolm's profession; she believed he was an investigator working with the legal-aid clinic.
Before he left, she gave him the photograph of Isaiah in his baseball uniform. “Don't let them turn my grandson into a case number,” she said. Malcolm carried the photograph ever since, a reminder that an investigation was supposed to protect people rather than merely produce arrests.
Now, in Franklin Park, the same photograph lay on the pavement while Haskell ordered Malcolm to turn around. Andre moved one careful step closer and said, “Officer, you need to secure your weapon and call your sergeant.” Haskell responded by pressing a hand against Andre's shoulder and pushing him toward the fence. Andre stumbled but caught himself, then held both palms against the metal bars.
Malcolm heard a phone recording begin somewhere behind him. A teenager named Hannah Cole, sitting at a picnic table with her brother, had raised her phone and was filming openly. Haskell noticed her and ordered her to stop. Hannah kept recording from a safe distance, her face pale but determined.
“You want to join them?” Haskell shouted at her. Hannah said she was standing on a public path and was not interfering. Haskell turned back toward the men, furious that his authority was being questioned in front of children. He unclipped his handcuffs and told Malcolm to kneel.
Malcolm complied slowly, feeling the old ache in his right knee, while Andre asked again for a supervisor. Haskell leaned close enough that Malcolm could smell mint gum on his breath. “I know exactly what you two are doing,” he whispered. “You're trying to stir up another complaint about the department, and I can make sure nobody hears it.”