It was the simple answer of a careful child who had been taught to look both ways. Obey the signal and speak clearly. When an adult asked a question, Mallerie heard something else. He shoved the transmission into park and opened his door. He was 38, broad through the chest and already angry from a shift that had begun with a reprimand about incomplete reports.
Sweat darkened the cloth beneath his body armor. He stepped into the crosswalk as if Aaliyah had summoned him there. What did you say? The walking sign was on. Put your hands where I can see them.
Aaliyah stared at him. They are. She lifted the pharmacy bag a little higher. Her other hand hung open at her side. Both hands.
Now I'm just going home. Turn around and face the vehicle. Why? The question changed his face. The irritation in his eyes hardened into certainty.
Mallerie had learned that certainty could conceal the absence of a reason. If he gave commands quickly enough, most people obeyed before asking whether he had the right to give them. Because I told you to put the bag down and turn around. Aaliyah looked toward the bakery, perhaps searching for an adult who could explain what was happening. That was when Mallerie reached for her.
He caught her left wrist and pulled. The movement spun her half around. The pharmacy bag crushed between them and one of the bottles slipped through a tear in the paper and bounced beneath the patrol car. Aaliyah cried out. Mallerie drove her shoulder against the rear door, placed his forearm across her back, and forced her downward.
"Stop fighting me. I'm not. I didn't do anything. " Her knees buckled. Her right palm struck the glass as she tried to keep her face from hitting it again.
The first witness to move closer was Dana Whitaker, a 54-year-old nurse who had stepped out of the bakery with a box of cupcakes for her grandson. She set the box on the sidewalk and held both hands where Mallerie could see them. "Officer, she isn't resisting," Dana said. I watched the whole thing. She had the walk signal.
Back up. She's crying. Let go of her arm. Back up now or you will be detained. Dana stopped, but she did not leave.
Beside her, the teenager with the bicycle moved closer to the curb and held his phone horizontally. His name was Malik Carter. He was 16 and his summer job at a hardware store had taught him to read names from uniforms and receipts carefully. Officer Trent Mallerie, he said for the recording. Westbridge Police Department badge number 417, 3:20 in the afternoon.
Laurel and North Mercer. Mallerie turned his head. The pressure on Aaliyah's back did not ease. Put that phone away. I'm on a public sidewalk.
You're interfering with an investigation. What investigation? More phones appeared. A man inside the delivery van recorded through his windshield. One of the bakery employees came outside.
A driver stopped at the red light and pointed her camera through the passenger window. Each new lens made Mallerie more aware that he was being observed. But instead of calming him, the attention made him perform authority more aggressively. This subject entered traffic without regard for an emergency vehicle. He announced she refused multiple lawful commands and became physically resistant.