Cop Pulled Over a Young Woman on a Ducati — Then Asked, “Is This Motorcycle Actually Yours?”

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

What I'm going to share with you about what I found is not something I'm required to share at this stage. I'm choosing to share it because I believe you are owed transparency and because the nature of what I found makes transparency the appropriate response. Is that understood? Understood, Samantha said. Mitchell opened her folder.

I reviewed the full body camera footage from Officer Carter, including the 12 minutes before he activated his emergency lights. She paused to let that land. Traffic stop body cameras in this department activate automatically when emergency lights are engaged. But the officer's body camera has a passive recording buffer it captures and stores the 60 seconds prior to activation. What that means is that I can see what officer Carter was doing and saying in the car during the period before he pulled you over.

Samantha sat very still. In that footage, Mitchell continued, "Officer Carter is heard making a comment to Officer Reynolds about the motorcycle." Specifically, he says, "And I'm reading directly from the transcript. Look at that. A Ducatti Panagalei.

You see who's riding it? No way. That's hers." Reynolds responds with, "We don't know that." Carter responds, "Run the plate."

Reynolds responds, "On what basis?" Carter says, "Just run it." The room was absolutely quiet. Samantha heard the air conditioning. She heard her own breathing.

She heard somewhere down the hall a phone ringing twice and then stopping. The plate came back clean, Mitchell said, as did the vent, the registration, the license, and the insurance. All of this was confirmed before officer Carter activated his lights. He pulled you over after confirming that every document associated with that motorcycle was current and valid. Samantha had known this.

She had felt it in her bones. The moment Carter had said everything checks out and then stood there anyway. But knowing something and hearing it stated aloud by a law enforcement sub was reading from an official transcript to ket were two fundamentally different experiences and the difference hit her somewhere behind her sternum with a force she hadn't fully prepared for. He saw me, she said. And yes, Mitchell said.

That's what the footage shows, a silence. What happens now? Samantha asked. I've initiated a formal internal review, Mitchell said. The footage, the transcript, the timeline discrepancy between his radio call in which he stated questionable VIN as the basis for the toe and the documented confirmation that the VIN was clean will all be part of that review.

Officer Reynolds will also be interviewed as a witness. Reynolds told Carter on what basis before the stop. Samantha said he knew. He raised an objection. Mitchell said carefully.

Whether that objection was sufficient, that's part of what the review will examine. I'm not looking to go after Reynolds, she said. I want to be clear about that. He was decent to me during the stop in the ways that he could be. Mitchell looked at her with an expression that was not quite surprise, but was adjacent to it, the look of someone who had expected anger and found something more considered instead.

News in the same category

Cop Pulled Over a Young Woman on a Ducati — Then Asked, “Is This Motorcycle Actually Yours?”

40 Part