I wanted to reach you before the department's communication goes out tomorrow morning. The initial findings of the formal review are complete. Samantha's hand tightened on the phone. Go ahead. The review panel found that the traffic stop of your vehicle on Oswin 14th was initiated without probable cause or reasonable articulable suspicion of a traffic violation.
Mitchell said, reading from what was clearly an official document, her voice was steady and precise. The pre-top recording establishes that the officer confirmed all vehicle documentation was valid prior to initiating the stop and that the decision to initiate the stop was based on a subjective assessment of the rers's appearance rather than any objectively articulable legal basis. Samantha closed her eyes for one second. Furthermore, Mitchell continued, "The stated justification for the vehicle tow, a questionable VIN, was found to be inconsistent with the officer's own prior verbal confirmation that the VIN had returned clean." The review panel found this inconsistency to be deliberate misrepresentation of investigative circumstances in an official radio communication.
Deliberate misrepresentation in an official radio communication. Those words were not administrative softening. Those words had consequences. What does that mean for Carter? She asked.
I can't discuss personnel actions in detail, Mitchell said. What I can tell you is that the finding has been forwarded to the department's professional standards bureau, which handles the next phase. That phase is not within my direct authority. A pause. What I can tell you is that the finding is not a reprimand.
It's a substantiated misconduct determination. That's a significant distinction. Yes, Samantha said it is. Officer Reynolds voluntary statement was incorporated into the record. Mitchell said his account corroborated your timeline and documentation at every point.
His statement was also the source of one piece of information that was not in your documentation. She paused again, deliberate this time, waited. Reynolds stated that during the period of the stop while you were waiting on the shoulder, officer Carter made a comment to him. Reynolds described it as Carter saying, "And again, I'm reading she thinks having that emblem protects her. Let's see how protected she is."
The shop was completely silent. Samantha heard those words and felt them land somewhere deep and specific not in her chest where anger lived but lower in the place settled when they were confirmed rather than suspected. He hadn't been trying to find a crime. He'd been trying to make a point. He'd seen the emblem, the memorial to her dead uncle, the MW, in custom metal work that she carried on every bike she'd ever owned.
and he'd read it as a provocation, as something that needed to be answered. And he'd decided that towing her motorcycle was the answer. "He wasn't looking for evidence, " she said, and her voice came out steadier than she felt. "He was making a statement." "That is the review panel's reading of the evidence, " Mitchell said carefully.