Cop Pours Drink On Black Woman At Diner — Then Someone Asked, “Do You Know Who She Is?”

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He told her. All three were holdovers from the previous DA's office. People who had been here long enough to have built comfortable relationships with the sheriff's department. Long enough to understand what it meant that the new DA had made headlines before her first official day. Viven noted the names.

She said nothing. She walked to her office, set down her briefcase, and got to work. By 9:00, she had submitted a formal written request to the sheriff's department for Officer Darwin Perinson's complete personnel file. Every complaint, every commendation, every internal review, every piece of paper with his name on it going back to his first day on the job. She sent it through official channels properly formatted with a response deadline of five business days as permitted under county records protocol.

By noon, Murphy appeared at her office door. They say it's being compiled. Viven looked up from the case file she was reviewing. Being compiled. That's the language they used.

Being compiled. She nodded slowly and went back to reading. By 4:00. Murphy was back. Processing delay.

She set her pen down. What kind of delay? They didn't specify. She looked at him for a moment. Then she picked her pen back up.

All right. At 5:00, her desk phone rang. The voice on the other end was warm and unhurried. The voice of a man who made calls like this the way other men made small talk. Sheriff Dale Odum, 61 years old, had run the Harlem County Sheriff's Department for 11 years.

He had a reputation for being reasonable, for being collegial, for being the kind of law enforcement leader that county commissioners like to photograph themselves standing next to. Ms. Monroe. He practically beamed through the line. Just wanted to call personally and say congratulations on your swearing in.

Long overdue, if you ask me. Really, this county needed some fresh energy in that office. Thank you, Sheriff. I mean it. And listen.

I just want you to know that my department's door is always open to you. Always. We've had a real productive working relationship with the DA's office over the years, and I know that's something we all want to preserve going forward. A brief, warm pause. I genuinely look forward to working with you.

Every word was perfect. Every word was a wall. I look forward to it as well, Vivian said. I'll follow up on that record's request first thing tomorrow. There was a beat, just one, barely a second long.

Of course, we'll get that sorted out for you real soon. She hung up. She sat back in her chair and looked at the ceiling for a moment. Then she looked at her office door. Murphy was in the hallway pretending to read something.

Murphy. He appeared in the doorway immediately. I need every civil complaint filed against any officer in this county over the last 10 years. Don't go through the sheriff's office. Go through the courts directly.

Filed records, public docket, anything that passed through a clerk's hands. Murphy wrote it down. All of them. Every single one. He nodded.

He started to turn away. Then he stopped. Vivien. He said it carefully, like a man testing the weight of a question before he asked it. "How big do you think this is? " she picked up her pen.

"I think," she said, "that we're just getting started. " Angela Pastton didn't knock so much as a pier. One moment Vivian's doorway was empty and the next it contained a woman of 51 with closecropped natural hair going silver at the temples. Reading glasses pushed up on her forehead and a manila envelope held against her chest like she had been carrying it for so long it had become part of her. She wore a press badge clipped to her jacket and the expression of someone who had been waiting a very long time to be in this exact room. Ms.

Monroe. She didn't wait to be invited. She stepped inside, pulled the door half closed behind her, and set the envelope on the desk between them. My name is Angela Pastton. I write for the Harland County Courier.

I've been trying to get someone to look at what's in that envelope for 2 years. Viven looked at the envelope, then at Angela. Sit down. Angela sat. What came out of that envelope landed on Vivian's desk in careful, organized layers.

The work of a woman who had been building something in private for a long time and knew exactly how to present it. Affidavit from six people who had filed formal complaints against officer Darwin Perinson between 2014 and 2023. Four black men and women, one Latino man, one white woman in her 70s who had lived in Harlem County her whole life and described what happened to her in three short paragraphs that were somehow worse for their brevity. Every single complaint had been dismissed. Everyone marked unsubstantiated, that flat bureaucratic word that meant in practice that someone with more power than the person complaining had decided the complaining should stop.

Three of the six complainants reported being pulled over by county officers within 2 weeks of filing. One man, a small business owner named Gio Morrison, who ran an auto repair shop on the east side, had a surprise health and safety inspection the week after he submitted his affidavit. The inspection turned up violations that had never been cited in seven previous inspections. His shop was fined. He withdrew the complaint.

"I took all of this to the previous DA," Angela said. Her voice was even, but there was something beneath it. The specific exhaustion of a person who had been right about something for a long time without anyone listening twice. The first time I got a meeting with a junior staffer. The second time I got a letter telling me the matters had been reviewed internally and found to be without merit.

Viven was still reading. Who else have you taken this to? County Oversight Board, State Press Association. I wrote the story twice. My editor killed it both times.

Different reasons each time, but the same result. She folded her hands on her knee. The first time he said there wasn't enough sourcing. The second time he said the timing wasn't right. And your editor, does he golf?

Angela looked at her. Every Saturday. He and Sheriff ODM have been in the same forsome for six years. Viven set the papers down. She looked at Angela Pastton directly at the two years in her face, the patience and the frustration living right next to each other and made a decision.

There's something else, Angela said. Denise Fuller has called the department twice about Perkinson specifically about his conduct toward her staff when he comes in on Tuesdays. She paused. Both calls were logged. Both were closed without action.

That diner is not just where this started, Ms. Monroe. It has history. Vivien was quiet for a moment. Come back Monday.

Angela nodded. She began gathering her documents. Leave the copies, Vivien said. That Thursday evening, Viven drove to a coffee shop 12 blocks from the diner and sat across from Cassie Burns, who arrived 5 minutes early in her work apron, hair still pulled back from her shift, hands wrapped around a cup she wasn't drinking from. Viven listened, all of it.

The Tuesdays, the comments, the particular way Perkinson spoke to the younger servers when Denise wasn't close enough to intervene. The silent understanding among the staff that you absorbed it and moved on because the alternative was worse. Cassie spoke quietly, carefully, like someone reading from a document they had kept locked inside themselves for months. When she finished, Vivien explained what a formal witness statement meant, what it required, what it did not obligate Cassie to do alone. Cassie was quiet for a long moment.

Then she said, "When you said it wasn't my fault in the diner. " "Why did you say that? You didn't even know me. " "Because it was true," Vivian said simply. "And because nobody had said it to you yet. " Cassie sat down her cup. She straightened in her chair, shoulders back, chin level, in the way of someone who has just decided something they won't be undeciding. "Okay," she said.

"I'll give the statement. " Pammy Owen lived in a neat brick house on the quiet end of Sycamore Drive with windchimes on the porch and a welcome mat that said blessed in faded letters. She answered the door in a cardigan and reading glasses. And when Murphy WZ showed his DA's office identification, she looked at it for a long moment before she looked at him. I figured someone would come, she said. She let him in.

Her living room was tidy and warm, framed family photos on the walls, a Bible on the side table, a television playing the morning news on low volume. She sat across from Murphy in a floral armchair and folded her hands in her lap and told him everything with the quiet, careful honesty of a woman confessing something she already knew she should have done differently. She had recorded for almost two full minutes. She had the whole thing, the pour, the laugh, Perinson's face, all of it. And then the captain had sat down across from her with his warm smile and his reasonable voice and suggested gently that personal recordings of officers could get complicated, that things could be misrepresented, that she seemed like a sensible woman, that sensible women understood how these situations worked.

She had deleted it before she got home. "I'm sorry," she said. She was looking at her hands. "I know what I saw. I know what I had and I just She stopped, pressed her lips together.

I got scared. That man had a badge and I'm 62 years old and I got scared. Murphy leaned forward. Mrs. Owen, before you deleted it, did you send any part of it to anyone?

She looked up. Something shifted in her expression. Not guilt this time, something closer to hope, the fragile, uncertain kind. My granddaughter, she said slowly. Katie.

I texted her while it was happening. Just a clip. I didn't even think about it. I just sent it because she always says I never tell her anything interesting. She paused.

I don't know how much she got. Murphy had his phone out before she finished the sentence. Katie Owen was 19 years old and a sophomore at Georgia State, and she did not intimidate easily. That was the first thing Vivien noticed when Katie walked into the DA's office Friday afternoon. The way she carried herself, unhurried and direct, like a young woman who had already decided she was going to do the right thing and was simply waiting for someone to point her in the right direction.

She had 17 seconds. She pulled up the clip on her phone and set it on Vivien's desk without preamble. Vivien watched it once, then again, then a third time. It was enough. The pour was clear.

The laugh was clear. And Perinson's voice, unhurried, satisfied, completely certain of itself, was unmistakable. Oops. My hand slipped. Then the laugh again.

Easy. Unbothered. The sound of a man who had never once considered that anything would come of it. Murphy watched it a fourth time. Then he went still.

Look at the background," he said quietly. Vivien looked in the far edge of the frame, slightly out of focus but completely visible, stood Cassie Burns, still holding the plate, face frozen in that hollow, stricken expression, shock and guilt, and the particular horror of someone who understood exactly what had just happened and felt responsible for all of it. It was everything Cassie's written statement described. It was right there in 17 seconds, corroborated without either of them knowing it. Viven sat back in her chair.

She looked at Katie. "Thank you. " "Is it enough? " Katie asked. "It's a very good start. " Vivian filed the clip into evidence before the day was out, put a litigation hold on it, and said nothing to Angela Pastton. She was not ready to move that piece yet. She needed to know the full shape of the board before she showed anyone what was in her hand.

That Saturday morning, she sat at Hector Sims's kitchen table for 2 hours. He was 71 years old, a retired postal worker with large hands and a quiet, measured way of speaking that told Vivien he had spent a lifetime being careful about what he said and to whom. He made coffee without asking if she wanted any. He set out a plate of butter cookies. Then he told her about 2018, about Perinson, about the complaint he filed and the two weeks that followed.

The patrol car that seemed to appear whenever he left his house, the registration notice that materialized out of nowhere and then disappeared just as quickly once he called the department to ask about withdrawing his complaint. I didn't withdraw it, he said firmly. I want you to know that I didn't withdraw it. I just stopped expecting anything from it. Sunday afternoon, Vivien drove to a church community room on the south side and sat with two more complaintants.

Different names, different years, different specific details, the same shape underneath all of it, the same unmistakable pattern of a system that had learned how to make problems disappear before they became inconvenient. By Sunday evening, she had personally spoken to all six people from Angela's files. Six different lives, six different stories, every single one ending the same way. I filed and then something happened to make me wish I hadn't. She drove home in the dark, the city moving past her windows and called Murphy.

We're not building a misconduct case, she said. We're building organized retaliation. That's a different animal entirely. A pause on the other end. How many people does that take down?

Murphy asked. Vivien kept her eyes on the road. I don't know yet, she said. Let's find out. Vivien had barely gotten through her front door when her phone rang.

She set her keys on the counter and looked at the screen. Denise Fuller. She picked up on the second ring. I've been watching, Denise said. No greeting, no preamble, just the voice of a woman who had made a decision and was moving before she could change her mind.

I've been watching you fight this thing all week. Watching them push back, watching that captain smile and that sheriff call and that judge. She stopped, took a breath. I have something. I've had it for 9 years and I think it's time I stopped holding it.

Vivien set her briefcase down slowly. Tell me. In 2015, Denise's nephew, Devon Fuller, was 22 years old. He worked the night shift at a logistics warehouse on the north end of the county. Loading, unloading, the kind of work that left your back sore and your hands rough and your body ready for bed the moment your feet hit the door.

He walked home most nights because his car was in the shop for 3 weeks that summer and the bus didn't run late enough to meet his shift. One night in August, Officer Darwin Perinson stopped him two blocks from his apartment. No cause, no explanation. Devon was walking on the sidewalk, minding every piece of his own business. And the patrol car rolled up slow beside him and the window came down and Perinson told him to put his hands where he could see them.

News in the same category

Cop Pours Drink On Black Woman At Diner — Then Someone Asked, “Do You Know Who She Is?”

5 Part