Cop Pointed at a Black Woman and Said, “She’s Lying” — Then She Took the Witness Stand

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The washing machines hummed below him. He sat on the edge of his bed, folded his hands, and stared at the wall. He did not know that 200 miles north, a woman he had never met was building a case that would give him his name back. The evidence sat on Isabelle's desk in three neat stacks. Stack one, three audio recordings.

Each one timestamped, each one capturing the same voice making the same demand on the same road. Different nights, different amounts, same man. Stack two, three dashcam videos. Each one showing a uniformed officer approaching a vehicle, leaning into the window, and walking away with cash in his pocket. The angles were not perfect.

The camera was built into the rearview-mirror housing, and Callaway's face was partially lit by his own flashlight. But the badge number was visible. The cruiser's unit number was visible. And in two of the three videos, the bills passing from her hand to his were visible. Stack three, her observation logs, dates, times, locations.

Plate numbers of every car that passed while Callaway was parked at mile marker four. 14 cars in one night. Three pulled over, all black. 11 let through, all white. Three nights of observation, the numbers did not vary.

Isabelle laid the three stacks side by side and looked at them. Any one of them would be enough to open an investigation. Together, they were a case. But she did not want a case. She wanted a conviction.

And not just for extortion. She picked up the phone and called the US Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Virginia. The prosecutor assigned was a woman named Katherine Bledsoe. Isabelle had worked with her twice before. Once in Norfolk, once in Charlottesville.

Bledsoe was thorough, patient, and hard to impress. Isabelle sent the files. Bledsoe reviewed them over two days. On the third day, she called back. "The recordings are clean," Bledsoe said.

"Chain of custody is solid. The dash cam corroborates the audio. The observation logs establish a pattern of racial targeting. This is enough for an arrest. " "I do not want an arrest," Isabelle said.

"Not yet. " Bledsoe was quiet. "If we arrest him now, he gets charged with extortion under color of law. Federal civil rights violation. He is looking at five to eight years.

And if we wait? " Bledsoe asked. "We let the victims file a civil rights lawsuit. Callaway will have to respond. He will take the stand.

And he will do what he has always done, Lie. Perjury. Bledsoe said. Perjury on top of civil rights violations. Isabelle said.

That is the difference between 8 years and 20. Bledsoe thought about it. She asked one question. You are confident he will deny everything? Isabelle almost laughed.

She thought about the man who had looked her in the eye on Route 9 and told her to find a different road. The man who had collected $40 from her three times without blinking. The man who had shaken the sheriff's hand on stage while his victims filed complaints that nobody read. He has never admitted anything to anyone. Isabelle said.

He is not going to start now. Bledsoe approved the strategy. Over the next 3 weeks, the FBI worked quietly. They contacted Diane Holloway, the civil rights attorney Marcus Redmond had found in Richmond. Holloway agreed to file the lawsuit on behalf of Marcus and 11 other victims.

The complaint alleged systematic civil rights violations by Sergeant Derek Callaway, racial profiling, extortion, false charges, and abuse of authority on Route 9. Isabelle's name appeared in the filing as a witness, listed under her cover identity. A woman who had been pulled over three times and forced to pay. Nothing in the document indicated she was law enforcement. Nothing indicated the recordings existed.

The evidence was sealed, held back, waiting for one thing. His testimony. The lawsuit was served to Callaway on a Friday morning. A deputy handed him the papers at the substation. Callaway read the cover page, looked at the list of plaintiffs, and tossed the folder onto his desk.

He told a colleague it was a nuisance suit. He said it would be dismissed within a month. He said the people filing it had no evidence, no credibility, and no chance. He was not worried. He had testified before in traffic court, in criminal proceedings and internal reviews.

Every time his word had been enough. Every time the other side had nothing. He had no reason to think this time would be different. He was wrong. But he did not know that yet.

The courtroom was full. Marcus Redmond sat in the second row behind the plaintiff's table. He wore the same suit, the only one he owned. Diane Holloway sat beside him, her files organized in two folders. Behind them, nine other plaintiffs filled the benches.

Terrence Odom, Sharon Okafor, Darnell Price. People who had been told their word meant nothing, sitting in a room where words were supposed to mean everything. Calloway walked in like a man arriving at his own commendation ceremony. He wore his dress uniform, polished badge, pressed collar. He nodded to his attorney.

He did not look at the plaintiffs. He did not look at the gallery. He sat down, adjusted his cuffs, and waited. When his attorney called him to the stand, Calloway stood up slowly. He placed his left hand on the Bible.

He raised his right hand. He swore to tell the truth, and then he lied. He lied with the steady voice of a man who had done it before. He lied with the posture of someone who believed the room belonged to him. He looked at the judge and spoke the way he always spoke, with authority, with certainty, with the absolute confidence of a person who had never been caught.

"I have served Ridgemont County for 16 years," Calloway said. "I have never accepted money from a motorist. I have never fabricated a citation. I have never targeted anyone based on race. These accusations are false, every single one of them.

His attorney walked him through the complaints one by one. Calloway denied each one. Marcus Redmond denied. Terrence Odom denied. Sharon Okafor denied.

Darnell Price denied. Each name, each story dismissed with the same flat certainty. Then his attorney asked about the woman listed as a witness. The one who claimed she had been stopped three times and forced to pay. Calloway leaned forward.

"That woman is lying," he said. He pointed across the courtroom at Isabelle, sitting at the end of the plaintiff's bench in a gray blazer. "She fabricated every accusation against me. I have never seen her before. I have never stopped her vehicle.

I have never taken a dollar from her or anyone else. " He said it looking directly at her. His jaw was tight. His voice was rising. He was not just denying, he was attacking.

Bury the accuser, discredit the witness. The same strategy that had worked 14 times before. Isabelle watched him speak. She did not move. She did not blink.

She sat with her hands folded, her back straight, and waited. Calloway finished his testimony. His attorney thanked him. He stepped down from the stand and returned to his seat. He leaned over to his lawyer and whispered something.

The lawyer nodded. Calloway sat back with his arms crossed. He thought it was over. Diane Holloway stood up. "Your Honor, the plaintiff calls our next witness.

" She turned toward the bench. "Would the witness please take the stand? " Isabelle Ogden stood up. She walked to the front of the courtroom, every step measured, every breath controlled. She passed Calloway's table.

He glanced at her. A flicker of recognition crossed his face. The car, the road, the plate number, but it was gone before it fully formed. She sat down in the witness chair. The clerk asked her to state her name.

Isabelle reached into her blazer. She pulled out a leather credential case and opened it flat on the witness stand. "My name is Isabelle Ogden. " She said. "I am a special agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation Civil Rights Division.

" The courtroom went silent. Not quiet silent. The kind of silence that happens when an entire room holds its breath at the same time. Calloway's arms uncrossed. His mouth opened slightly.

His eyes locked on the badge. Isabelle continued. Her voice did not waver. "Over the course of 6 weeks, I was stopped three times by Sergeant Derek Calloway on Route 9. Each time he demanded cash payment in exchange for not filing fabricated citations.

Each encounter was recorded audio and video using FBI-issued surveillance equipment. The recordings are time-stamped, court-admissible, and have been in the custody of the US Attorney's Office since they were made. " She looked at Calloway. "Every statement Sergeant Calloway just made under oath that he never stopped me, never took money from me, never saw me before is false, and I have the recordings to prove it. " Calloway approached the bench with a laptop.

She pressed play. Calloway's voice filled the courtroom. Clear. Unmistakable. "40 or I write you.

" The gallery erupted. Marcus Redmond pressed both hands flat on the bench in front of him. His lips were trembling, but his eyes were dry. Terrence Odom dropped his head into his hands. Sharon Okafor grabbed the arm of the woman sitting next to her and squeezed.

Calloway sat frozen. His attorney was saying something to him, but he was not listening. He was staring at the badge on the witness stand, the badge that belonged to the woman he had told to find a different road. The second recording played, then the third. Each one the same voice, the same demand, the same road.

By the time the third recording ended, Callaway's attorney had stopped talking. The judge had removed her glasses, and every person in that courtroom understood what had just happened. Derek Callaway had not been caught by an investigation. He had not been caught by a tipster or a surveillance team. He had been caught by his own testimony given 3 minutes ago under oath in his own words denying something that had been recorded from three different angles on three different nights.

He had buried himself, and he had done it with his own voice. Katherine Bledsoe was waiting outside the courtroom. She had been there since the trial began, seated in the back row, a federal observer in a county proceeding watching Callaway testify the way a chess player watches an opponent move into checkmate. When Isabel's recordings finished playing, Bledsoe stood up. She walked to the front of the courtroom, introduced herself to the judge, and presented a sealed federal indictment.

The charges: extortion under color of law, deprivation of civil rights, and perjury. The perjury count was based on the testimony Callaway had given less than 10 minutes earlier. His own words, his own voice, under his own oath. Two federal marshals entered through the side door. Callaway did not resist.

News in the same category

Cop Pointed at a Black Woman and Said, “She’s Lying” — Then She Took the Witness Stand

4 Part