David smiled. You really want to peel the onion? I want to burn the onion, Marcus replied. They filed the lawsuit the next day. Sterling v.
City of Oak Creek at all. The complaint alleged unlawful search and seizure, false arrest, excessive force, and malicious prosecution. It demanded $2.1 million in damages and more importantly a declaratory judgment that the department's policies were unconstitutional. The discovery phase was devastating. When the city was forced to turn over Brangan's files, the pattern Marcus suspected was there in black and white.
In his 18 months on the force, Brangan had initiated 24 suspicious person stops. 22 of them were black or Hispanic men. None of them had resulted in a conviction for any property crime. Most were dismissed. But the smoking gun was a memo from Branigan's previous sergeant written 6 months prior.
It read, "Officer Branigan struggles with deescalation and shows a concerning tendency to assert authority aggressively when challenged by minority residents, recommend remedial training or transfer to a non-prolol role. " The memo had been signed by the lieutenant and filed away. No training was ordered. No transfer happened. They had known he was a liability and they had left him on the street with a gun. "There it is," David said, holding the document up during a deposition.
"Diberate indifference. The city knew he was dangerous and did nothing. That pierces their immunity. " The deposition of Officer Branigan was brutal. Under oath, stripped of his badge and uniform, he looked small. David Patterson walked him through the video frame by frame.
Officer, at this moment, what crime was being committed? None. At this moment, did you have a warrant? No. At this moment, did you know who owned the house?
No. So, you tackled a man on his own property based on a hunch? I was following procedure. Then the procedure is unconstitutional, David said. The settlement conference took place 6 months later.
The city manager, the police chief, and the city attorney sat on one side. Marcus and David sat on the other. The city attorney looked exhausted. Dr. Sterling, we are prepared to offer the full amount demanded in the suit, $2.1 million.
We admit no liability, but we want to close this chapter. Money is fine, Marcus said, his hands folded on the table. But I have conditions. Conditions, the chief bristled. This is a monetary settlement.
Not anymore, Marcus said. If you want me to sign, Officer Branigan is terminated immediately. Not allowed to resign, terminated for cause. And you will report the termination to the state certification board so he cannot be hired by the department down the road. He loses his badge forever.