Cop Pointed a Gun at a Black Man in His Own Garage — Then Learned He Was the Homeowner

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They walked through the heavy steel doors into the processing area. The smell of the station was familiar to anyone who watched crime dramas, stale coffee floor wax, and misery. But for Marcus, it was a foreign world. They approached the booking desk. The desk sergeant was Thomas Miller, a grizzled veteran with 30 years on the force.

He was drinking a coffee and reading a sports blog on his computer. He didn't look up initially. "Got a refusal to identify resisting and obstruction," Branigan announced, placing Marcus' wallet, which he had fished out of the back pocket during the pat down on the counter. "Saturday morning special, huh? " Sergeant Miller grunted. "What's the story?

Suspect was in a garage in Oak Creek, acting suspicious, refused to show ID, got belligerent. " Miller looked up. He looked at Branigan. Then he looked at the suspect. The coffee cup stopped halfway to Miller's mouth. His eyes widened.

He squinted as if trying to process an image that didn't make sense. He looked at the grease stained coveralls, then at the face. "Holy," Miller whispered. He stood up so fast his chair rolled back and hit the filing cabinets. "Dr.

Sterling," Marcus nodded politely. "Good morning, Sergeant Miller. I believe we met at the policeman's ball last year. I was the guest speaker. Miller's face went pale.

He looked at Branigan with an expression of pure horror. Branigan, you arrested Dr. Sterling, the chief of neurosurgery at St. Jude's. Branigan blinked.

I He wouldn't show ID. He was in a garage. In his garage. Miller roared, his voice echoing off the concrete walls. He lives in Oak Creek.

Everyone knows he lives in Oak Creek. Did you run the plates? I I was investigating a suspicious person. You arrested the man who saved Lieutenant Kowalsski's life after that shooting last year. Miller came around the desk.

Get those cuffs off him now. But Sarge, he resisted. I said get them off. Miller barked. And don't you dare touch him again.

Miller turned to Marcus, his hands raised in apology. Doctor, I am so sorry. I don't know what this rookie was thinking. We're going to get this sorted out right now. Brangan uncuffed Marcus.

The metal clicked open and Marcus rubbed his wrists. There were deep red indentations. Sergeant Miller, Marcus said softly. I appreciate your intervention, but the time for sorting it out was back in my driveway before your officer pointed a loaded nine lemimeir at my chest. The station went quiet.

Other officers in this booking room stopped what they were doing. He drew on you, Miller asked, his voice low. He did, Marcus confirmed. And then he tackled me. I believe my right shoulder may have a rotator cuff strain.

I'll need that documented. Miller looked at Brangan. You drew down on a doctor for a trespassing call. I felt threatened. Brangan stammered.

He had a wrench. A torque wrench. Marcus corrected. I was fixing my car. Miller picked up the phone.

Get the watch commander down here and wake up the chief. I don't care that he's golfing. Tell him we have a code red situation. The next hour was a masterclass in bureaucratic panic. Marcus was ushered into the watch commander's office, not a holding cell.

He was offered coffee water, a comfortable chair, and an ice pack for his shoulder. He accepted the water and the ice pack, but refused to engage in small talk. Captain Reynolds, the watch commander, arrived in 10 minutes looking like he had sprinted from the parking lot. He was a tall man who usually projected authority, but today he looked like a man trying to diffuse a bomb with a hammer. "Dr.

Sterling," Reynold said, closing the door. "I've reviewed the initial report. This This looks like a massive misunderstanding. Officer Branigan is young. He's zealous.

He made a mistake in judgment regarding the context of the situation. A mistake in judgment is forgetting to signal a turn, Marcus said, holding the ice pack to his shoulder. Profiling a homeowner entering private property without a warrant and assaulting a citizen is not a mistake. It is a pattern of conduct. We understand your frustration.

We are going to release you immediately. No charges will be filed. Obviously, the obstruction charge won't stick given the circumstances. We can have a patrol car take you home right now. We can keep this quiet.

Marcus looked at the captain. Keep it quiet, Captain. My neighbor, Mrs. Gable, has already uploaded the video to the cloud. My attorney is likely drafting a filing as we speak.

You cannot unarrest me to make this go away. Dr. Be reasonable. We can handle this internally. Brangan will be disciplined, but if we make this a federal case, it already is a federal case.

Marcus interrupted. It became one when he violated my civil rights. Captain, do you know what I was thinking about when he had me on the ground? I wasn't thinking about my safety. I was thinking about the 18-year-old boy in the inner city who doesn't have my title, who doesn't have my money, and who doesn't have Mrs.

Gable recording. What happens to him when Officer Brangan decides he looks suspicious? He doesn't get a meeting in the commander's office. He gets a record or a funeral. The captain sighed, rubbing his temples.

What do you want, doctor? I want the full incident report. I want the body camera footage preserved and a chain of custody established immediately. I want the dispatch logs, and I want to walk out of the front door on my own to wait for my wife, who is coming to pick me up. I will not sign any release of liability.

I can't just give you the footage without a subpoena. Then consider this your notice that a subpoena is coming Monday morning. If 1 second of that footage is corrupted, lost, or accidentally deleted, I will make sure the Department of Justice investigates this precinct for obstruction of justice. Am I clear? Crystal clear, Reynolds said defeated.

10 minutes later, Sarah Sterling burst into the station lobby. She was a fierce woman, a professor of history, and she was currently in a state of terrified rage. When she saw Marcus walking out from the secure area, she ran to him, checking him for injuries. "I'm fine, Sarah," Marcus said, holding her. "I'm fine. " "They arrested you in our driveway," she sobbed.

"Yes. " Captain Reynolds and Sergeant Miller watched from the doorway. Branigan was nowhere to be seen. He had been ordered to sit in an interrogation room and not move a muscle. As Marcus and Sarah walked toward the exit, Marcus stopped. He turned back to the officers.

"Gentlemen," Marcus said. "You have a cancer in your department. You can cut it out or you can let it kill the whole patient. I suggest you decide quickly. " He pushed open the heavy glass doors and stepped out into the sunlight. The nightmare of the arrest was over.

The nightmare for the city of Oak Creek was just beginning. By Monday morning, the video titled Doctor Arrested for Fixing Car had 3 million views on social media. The visual was undeniable. The contrast between the calm, wellspoken older man in coveralls and the screaming aggressive young officer was jarring. The moment when Brangan tackled the doctor caused viewers to physically wse.

The comments section was a firestorm of outrage from across the political spectrum. Libertarians were furious about the property rights violation. Civil rights activists were pointing to the racial profiling. Car enthusiasts were offended that anyone would interrupt a man working on a 67 Shelby. Marcus sat in the conference room of Patterson and Finch, the city's most aggressive civil rights law firm.

David Patterson, the senior partner and an old friend of Marcus, threw a stack of papers on the table. It's a slam dunk, Marcus. They know it. I just got off the phone with the city attorney. He sounded like he was at a funeral.

He wants to settle immediately. No settlement yet, Marcus said. We need Discovery. Discovery, Marcus. They're offering to write a check to make this go away.

Why drag it out? Because I want to know if he's done this before, Marcus said. I want his personnel file. I want his disciplinary history. I want the stop and frisk data for zone 4 since he started.

David smiled. You really want to peel the onion? I want to burn the onion, Marcus replied. They filed the lawsuit the next day. Sterling v.

City of Oak Creek at all. The complaint alleged unlawful search and seizure, false arrest, excessive force, and malicious prosecution. It demanded $2.1 million in damages and more importantly a declaratory judgment that the department's policies were unconstitutional. The discovery phase was devastating. When the city was forced to turn over Brangan's files, the pattern Marcus suspected was there in black and white.

In his 18 months on the force, Brangan had initiated 24 suspicious person stops. 22 of them were black or Hispanic men. None of them had resulted in a conviction for any property crime. Most were dismissed. But the smoking gun was a memo from Branigan's previous sergeant written 6 months prior.

It read, "Officer Branigan struggles with deescalation and shows a concerning tendency to assert authority aggressively when challenged by minority residents, recommend remedial training or transfer to a non-prolol role. " The memo had been signed by the lieutenant and filed away. No training was ordered. No transfer happened. They had known he was a liability and they had left him on the street with a gun. "There it is," David said, holding the document up during a deposition.

"Diberate indifference. The city knew he was dangerous and did nothing. That pierces their immunity. " The deposition of Officer Branigan was brutal. Under oath, stripped of his badge and uniform, he looked small. David Patterson walked him through the video frame by frame.

Officer, at this moment, what crime was being committed? None. At this moment, did you have a warrant? No. At this moment, did you know who owned the house?

No. So, you tackled a man on his own property based on a hunch? I was following procedure. Then the procedure is unconstitutional, David said. The settlement conference took place 6 months later.

The city manager, the police chief, and the city attorney sat on one side. Marcus and David sat on the other. The city attorney looked exhausted. Dr. Sterling, we are prepared to offer the full amount demanded in the suit, $2.1 million.

We admit no liability, but we want to close this chapter. Money is fine, Marcus said, his hands folded on the table. But I have conditions. Conditions, the chief bristled. This is a monetary settlement.

Not anymore, Marcus said. If you want me to sign, Officer Branigan is terminated immediately. Not allowed to resign, terminated for cause. And you will report the termination to the state certification board so he cannot be hired by the department down the road. He loses his badge forever.

The room went silent. The police union would fight that. It was unprecedented to demand a firing as part of a civil settlement. We can't guarantee the certification board's decision, the city attorney said. Then you will testify at the hearing, Marcus countered.

You will present the evidence we found. You will do everything in your power to ensure he never carries a weapon under the color of law again. Or we can go to trial and I will put the chief on the stand and ask him about that memo he ignored. The chief looked at the city manager. The city manager looked at the budget forecast for a jury trial loss.

Done. The city manager said he's gone. One more thing. Marcus said the department will implement a mandatory policy. No ID checks on private property without reasonable articulable suspicion of a specific crime.

Suspicious person is not enough. You will write that into the manual and you will name it the Sterling rule. The chief ground his teeth. Fine. The papers were signed.

The fallout was swift. Kyle Brangan was fired the next day. The union tried to make noise, but the video was too damning. And the discovery of the ignored memo made him radioactive. He was descertified by the state board 3 months later.

At 28, his career in law enforcement was over. He ended up working as a dispatcher for a trucking logistics company, answering phones far away from any position of power. Marcus sat in his garage. It was Saturday morning, one year after the incident. The garage door was open.

The spring breeze was blowing. The 1967 Mustang sat on its tires, the suspension work finally finished. He held the check for $1.4 million, the post tax, postlegal fee amount, in his hand. It was a life-changing amount of money for most people. For Marcus, it was a tool.

He picked up his phone and called David. It's time to set up the trust, Marcus said. The Sterling Justice Initiative," David asked. "Yes, I want this money to pay for legal defense for homeowners who can't afford you. The next time a Branigan tries to bully a janitor or a teacher in their own driveway, I want a lawyer there within the hour. " "You're a good man, Marcus.

I'm a lucky man," Marcus corrected. "That's the problem. " He hung up the phone. He walked over to the Mustang and wiped a speck of dust from the fender. He picked up his torque wrench, the same tool that had almost gotten him killed. He waited in his hand.

It was heavy, solid, reel. He looked out at the street. A patrol car drove by. It was a new officer, a young woman. She slowed down, looked at Marcus, and gave a polite wave.

Marcus watched her carefully. He didn't wave back immediately. He waited to see if she would keep driving. She did. Only then did he raise his hand.

News in the same category

Cop Pointed a Gun at a Black Man in His Own Garage — Then Learned He Was the Homeowner

2 Part