Cop Handcuffed a Black Man Sitting on His Own Porch — Then He Took the Man to Booking Anyway

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I were not all like that. " "I know you're not," Marcus said. "I've signed hundreds of warrants for good officers. I've sent criminals to prison based on the work of good officers. But you have a cancer in this department, Sergeant. And today, that cancer tried to operate on the wrong patient.

10 minutes later, station commander Captain Frank Russo burst into the office. He was wearing jeans and a polo shirt, his badge clipped to his belt. He was breathless, his hair disheveled. "Judge Thorne," he gasped, extending a hand. My god, I am so sorry.

I came as soon as I heard. Marcus didn't stand. He shook the hand briefly. Captain Russo, we have met before at the bar association dinner last year. Yes, yes, I remember, Russo said, wiping sweat from his brow.

Judge, please tell me you're okay. Do you need medical attention? My shoulder is injured, Marcus said. I will be seeing my own physician right now. I want to talk about Officer Braden.

He's done. Russo said immediately. I'll suspend him pending investigation right now. Will, Captain, Marcus interrupted his voice sharp. Do not treat this as a standard internal affairs matter.

This is a federal civil rights violation. I am going to file a lawsuit. I am going to the press and I'm going to demand a Department of Justice review of your department's stop and frisk statistics. Russo pald. Judge, surely we can handle this internally.

We can terminate him. We can make sure he never works again. But a DOJ review that puts the whole department under the microscope. Maybe that's exactly where you need to be. Marcus said, "If this officer felt comfortable doing this to me in broad daylight in front of witnesses, what is he doing to the young men in the housing projects on the south side at 2:00 a.m.

When there are no cameras? What is he doing to the people who can't call the chief marshall? " Russo was silent. There was no answer to that question. "I want copies of everything before I leave," Marcus said. "And I want my wife called.

She is likely frantic. "We called her, sir," Miller said gently. "She's in the lobby. She brought She brought your lawyer. " Marcus walked out of the inner sanctum of the precinct into the lobby. Eleanor was there, her face stre with tears, standing next to David Gentry, a civil rights attorney known for being a shark in the courtroom.

When Eleanor saw Marcus, she ran to him, hugging him carefully. Detailed," she whispered. "Linda called me. She said he dragged you. Are you hurt? " "I'll be fine," Marcus said, kissing her forehead.

He looked at David. "You ready to work on a Sunday, David? For you always? " David said, his eyes scanning Marcus's appearance, noting the dirt on the sweatshirt and the redness on the wrists. "This is going to be a blood bath, Marcus. " Back in the secure hallway, Captain Russo walked to interrogation room 2. He opened the door.

Officer Braden was sitting at the metal table, his head in his hands. He looked up when the door opened. "Cap, I didn't know," Braden pleaded. "He didn't show me ID. He was being difficult. " "Shut up," Russo said.

It wasn't a shout. It was a resignation. "Do you have any idea what you've done? That wasn't just a judge. That was Magistrate Judge Thorne.

He writes the rules regarding search and seizure for this entire district. But he was on the porch. He looked Braden trailed off. He looked what, Kyle? Russo asked.

He looked black. Is that it? Braden didn't answer. I checked your logs. Russo said, throwing a file folder onto the table.

I should have done it months ago, but I did it just now. In the last year, 80% of your suspicious person stops were black males over the age of 40. Doctors, teachers, engineers. You have a pattern, Kyle. And nobody caught it because none of them were federal judges until today.

I'm not a racist, Braden whispered, the defense sounding hollow even to his own ears. You're a liability, Russo said. Give me your badge. Give me your gun. You're suspended without pay.

Effective immediately. The union rep is on his way, but I'm telling you right now, don't get comfortable. You're never wearing a uniform in this state again. Braden unpinned the badge from his shirt. His fingers fumbled with the clasp.

He laid the silver shield on the table. It clattered loudly in the small room. He unholstered his weapon and placed it next to the badge. He felt naked, smaller. Get out of my station," Russo said.

Braden walked out the back door, avoiding the lobby where he knew the judge was standing. He walked to his personal car, a lifted pickup truck. He sat in the driver's seat and stared at the steering wheel. He thought about his mortgage. He thought about his identity.

For 6 years, he had been Officer Braden. Now, he was just Kyle, and soon he would be a defendant. Inside the station, Marcus collected the USB drive containing the footage. He shook hands with Sergeant Miller, ignoring Russo. He walked out into the sunlight with Elellanor and David.

"What do you want to do? " David asked. "We can file tomorrow morning. " "File," Marcus said. "Sue them for everything. Violation of the fourth violation of the 14th false arrest battery emotional distress. Name the city.

Name the chief. Name Braden individually. It'll take years, David warned. I have time, Marcus said. And I have the truth.

The lawsuit Thornne via city of Hybridge at all hit the docket on Monday morning. By Tuesday, the story had leaked. The Washington Post ran the headline, "Federal judge handcuffed on own porch for shopping while black. " The body camera footage was released by David Gentry's office on Wednesday. The video went viral within hours. It was viewed millions of times.

The contrast was too sharp to ignore the calm, articulate older man quoting case law versus the aggressive younger officer escalating violence without cause. The moment when the neighbors intervened and Braden screamed at them became a sound bite on every news channel. The internal affairs investigation was swift, mostly because the evidence was irrefutable. But the real damage came from the discovery phase of the lawsuit. David Gentry requested Braden's entire disciplinary file and every stop report he had ever written.

What they found was a systemic failure. Braden had been the subject of six previous complaints for similar behavior. All had been dismissed as unfounded by his previous supervisor, a lieutenant who had since retired. The data showed that Braden patrolled affluent mixed race neighborhoods and exclusively stopped minority residents. He viewed them as intruders in their own communities.

The city attorney, a woman named Sarah Jenkins, called David Gentry 3 weeks into the suit. We want to settle, she said. I'm listening, David said, putting the phone on speaker so Marcus could hear. They were in Marcus's study, the same house where the arrest happened. We'll offer 500,000, Jenin said.

And Braden is already terminated. He's being descertified by the state board. Not enough, Marcus said, speaking up. Judge Thorne, Jenkins said, surprised. That's a standard offer for a wrongful arrest with minor physical injuries.

This isn't about my shoulder, Miss Jenkins, Marcus said. This is about a pattern and practice of civil rights violations that your department ignored. I want $2.5 million and I want a consent decree requiring independent auditing of all suspicious person stops for the next 5 years. 2.5 is the city council will never approve that. Jenkins stammered.

Then we go to trial. Marcus said calmly. I will take the stand. I will play that video and I will let a jury decide how much it costs to drag a federal magistrate off his porch in front of his neighbors. And Ms.

Jenkins, "You know the jury pool in this district, they don't like bullies. " There was a long silence on the other end. "I'll call you back," Jenkins said. 2 days later, the city agreed. $2.5 million, the largest settlement for a single wrongful arrest in the city's history. But the money came with strings attached by Marcus. He didn't keep a dime.

He announced the creation of the Thorn Legal Defense Fund. The entire 2.5 million would be used to provide top tier legal representation for indigent defendants who claimed they were victims of racial profiling and unlawful stops. He was taking the city's money and using it to fight the city's bad habits. Officer Kyle Braden was not only fired, he was charged criminally with assault and deprivation of rights. Though he eventually pleaded down to a misdemeanor to avoid prison time, his life, as he knew it, was over.

He couldn't work in security. He couldn't own a firearm. He moved two states away, working in a warehouse forever. The guy from that video 6 months later, Sunday morning returned to Crest View Lane. The leaves on the oak trees had turned to gold and amber.

The air was colder, hinting at the coming winter. Marcus Thorne sat in his wicker chair. A fresh cup of coffee steamed on the table. A new issue of the law review lay open. His shoulder still achd when it rained a permanent reminder of the metal cuffs, but his range of motion had mostly returned.

He watched the street. A police car drove by. It was a new officer, a young black woman this time. She slowed down as she passed the house. She waved respectfully.

Marcus nodded back. It was a victory. He had won. He had exposed a bad cop forced policy changes and created a fund that was already helping dozens of people. He had received letters from across the country thanking him for his courage.

But as the patrol car disappeared around the bend, Marcus didn't feel triumphant. He felt tired. He picked up his coffee cup, his hand trembling just slightly, not from age, but from a residual trauma that no amount of legal expertise could fully erase. He looked at the spot on the driveway where Braden had stood. He replayed the conversation in his head.

"You live around here? " Marcus set the cup down. He thought about the outcome. He was a federal magistrate. He knew the law. He had wealthy neighbors who were lawyers and doctors.

He had the chief of police on speed dial. He had every advantage a citizen could possibly have. And it still happened. The terror of that thought lingered in the silence of the porch. If it could happen to him with all his power and privilege, what chance did a 19-year-old kid in a hoodie have?

What chance did the mechanic driving home from a late shift have? He had won the battle, but the war was vast and ancient. He realized that his robe, his gavel, his title. They were just costumes.

Underneath, in the eyes of men like Kyle Braden, he was just a body to be controlled. Marcus closed the law review. He didn't feel like reading about justice today. He just wanted to sit on his porch in his home and breathe the air of a freedom that felt a little more fragile than it had before.

News in the same category

Cop Handcuffed a Black Man Sitting on His Own Porch — Then He Took the Man to Booking Anyway

3 Part