The deposition ended after several hours. Rachel told Edward he had been consistent with the video and previous statements. He said consistency was easier when he did not try to improve the past in the retelling. At home, however, he was exhausted enough to leave his shoes in the hall and sit without making dinner. Eleanor brought a pot of soup and found him staring at Miriam's photograph. She did not ask how the deposition had gone. She put the soup on the stove, set out two bowls, and waited until he was ready to talk.
"They asked whether I meant to embarrass him," Edward said eventually. Eleanor looked puzzled. "By standing in your own garden?" "By explaining what the law required." She let the question rest for a moment. Then she asked why embarrassment seemed to carry so much weight in discussions about an officer who had frightened and hurt someone else. Edward said it was easier for institutions to understand a conflict between personalities than a failure of power. Eleanor stirred her soup. "Then I hope the lawyer understands the difference before this is over," she said.
The city attorney studied the deposition that night. He had expected a respected former instructor to be a compelling witness, but he had hoped a few difficult questions might make the case less certain. Instead the answers made it harder to argue that Edward had provoked the encounter in any meaningful legal sense. The attorney called the city's risk manager and explained that the footage, medical records, and evidence of prior complaints created substantial exposure. The risk manager asked whether the city could settle without admitting everything plaintiffs alleged. The attorney said that was a negotiable question, but pretending no problem existed was no longer a realistic strategy.
Kessler's attorney argued that his client had been confronting uncertainty, not acting from prejudice. A citizen holding sharp tools could pose a risk, the attorney said, and an officer had to make quick decisions. Rachel acknowledged that officers faced genuine dangers. She returned the discussion to what the video showed after the shears were placed on the ground, after Edward identified himself as the homeowner, and after the license confirmed the address. Each new piece of information should have reduced the perceived threat. Instead, the officer's response had become more forceful.
The outside criminal investigation took longer than Edward wished. Investigators interviewed neighbors separately, examined body-camera footage, and compared the recorded language with Kessler's written report. The camera did not reveal the man's thoughts. It did reveal movements, requests, and the absence of physical resistance during crucial moments. Prosecutors evaluated possible assault and official-misconduct charges under state law, applying standards higher than those required for administrative discipline. Edward did not demand that they skip those standards. He demanded that they use them.
The criminal case review continued. Investigators compared Kessler's statements with the footage and evaluated whether the discrepancies were deliberate. They could not infer intent merely because a report was wrong. They could, however, examine whether an officer continued to make claims after objective evidence contradicted them. Prosecutors sought additional testimony about the booking statement and the alleged resistance. Edward provided what he remembered without embellishment. He found himself correcting a prosecutor who summarized an officer's movement too strongly. The prosecutor looked surprised, then amended the note.