Sit. Down. She sat. In the front row of the gallery, Sandra Holloway, who had slipped in during the footage playback and taken the seat beside Eleanor without either woman acknowledging the other, was writing in a small leather notebook with the focused intensity of someone who understood that what she was witnessing would be referred to for years.
And Colleen Marsh was sitting very still at the prosecution table, her overturned iPad in front of her, her press release half drafted inside it. And she was doing the arithmetic of the next 10 minutes with the terrified precision of someone watching a building fall. Marcus reached for the next file. Now, he said, let's talk about 15 years.
The folder was thick. Not dramatically thick. Not the kind of thickness you see in movies spilling paper across courtroom floors. Just the quiet, dense thickness of a document that has been compiled carefully, page by page, over a long time by people who understood that details matter, and that details once recorded do not disappear.
Marcus opened it without ceremony. " It's Officer Derek Callaway," he said. " Badge 1147. 12 years with the Eastfield Police Department.
Two department commendations. One letter of appreciation from the mayor's office dated 2019." He looked up briefly. " And 38 formal complaints filed against you since the beginning of your service.
The number landed in the room like a weight dropped from a height. Callaway said nothing. He was still standing. His hands had found each other behind his back in the posture of a man trying to hold himself together through muscle memory. "
38 complaints," Marcus repeated. " Reviewed and closed by the department's Internal Affairs Division. Every single one marked" He turned a page. " Unsubstantiated.
In 12 years, 38 complaints, zero findings of misconduct." He paused. " I want the room to sit with that number for a moment." He let them.
Rachel Kim was writing without looking down at her notepad. Her eyes were fixed on Marcus. Her hand was moving entirely from memory. " Complaint number four," Marcus said. "
Filed March 2013. Mrs. Denise Hartley, 61 years old, retired postal worker. Alleged that Officer Callaway stopped her vehicle on Auburn Avenue, referred to her using a racial slur, and searched her car without consent or probable cause. Her complaint included the names of two witnesses who were present.
He turned the page. Internal Affairs interviewed neither witness. Case closed in 11 days. Unsubstantiated.