The suspect? You mean Judge Brooks? A 72year-old woman with a cane? I didn't know who she was, but you knew she was elderly. You knew she had mobility issues.
You knew witnesses were trying to explain. Why did you assume guilt? Kane's jaw tightened. In my experience, people near exits with unpaid merchandise are usually shoplifting. In your experience, based on what data?
What training? Based on 20 years of police work, Daniel pulled up Kane's record. In 20 years, how many shoplifting arrests have you made at Morrison Supermarket? Cain hesitated. I don't know the exact number.
Zero. Officer Kane. You had made zero shoplifting arrests at that location. So, this wasn't based on experience. What was it based on?
Cain's face flushed. I was doing my job. Were you angry that day? No. Were you angry at Judge Brooks specifically?
Morrison objected, but the question hung in the air. Daniel shifted tactics. Officer Kaine, did you know your father was investigated for police brutality in the 1970s? That was a witch hunt. My father was a hero.
Was he? We've heard testimony about beatings, racial targeting, and deliberate cruelty. We've seen photographs. We've heard from witnesses. Was your father a hero or was he protected by the same system that protected you?
Cain stood abruptly, his voice rising. My father served this city honorably. That judge, he pointed at Ellie. She tried to destroy his reputation because she had an agenda against cops. Judge Mendes banged her gavl.
Officer Kain sit down. Cain sat breathing hard, but the damage was done. The jury had seen his rage, his resentment, and the generational hatred he carried. Daniel's voice was quiet now. You arrested Judge Brooks not because she was shoplifting, but because on some level, conscious or not, you wanted to punish her for what you believe she did to your father.
Isn't that true? No, Cain whispered, but his conviction had shattered. No further questions. The trial recessed for the day. Outside, reporters surrounded both legal teams.
Maya's latest podcast episode analyzing the testimony had already gone viral. Inside a courthouse bathroom, Cain stared at his reflection. His mother's words echoed. Your father wasn't the hero you think he was. And now, standing in a courtroom where his own actions were being dissected, he wondered if he was becoming the same kind of man.
That evening, Ellie sat with Maya and Henry in her living room. The news played coverage of the trial, but she didn't watch. Instead, she looked at a photograph of William. "Do you think we'll win?" Maya asked, "Win, lose?