Wrench sat down heavily on the workbench stool. “We failed that.”
Eleanor looked at the photo. “Some of you did. Some of you tried again.”
“You make that sound easier than it is.”
“It isn’t easy. That’s why it counts.”
Wrench told her more about the night Arthur left. The vote had not been about drugs, not yet. It had been about whether the club would provide “security” for a businessman willing to pay them to intimidate union organizers. Arthur recognized what the decision meant before most others did. Once the club sold fear, he said, it would keep needing customers.
Only Wrench voted with him.
Eleanor had assumed Arthur left surrounded by enemies. Instead, Wrench revealed that several members begged him to stay after the meeting. Arthur refused because he believed losing the vote meant losing the club’s direction. He packed his vest, met Eleanor at the courthouse the next morning, and never attended another formal meeting.
“Did he regret it?” Eleanor asked.
“Leaving? No.” Wrench looked toward the garden. “Losing us? Every day.”
That answer explained a sadness Eleanor had noticed but never named. Arthur rarely talked about old friends, yet he listened whenever motorcycles passed their house. He would pause at the kitchen window until the engines faded, then return to whatever he had been doing. Eleanor used to think he missed riding. Now she knew he missed belonging.
The federal case widened beyond what anyone expected. Investigators traced Crossland money into campaign donations, consulting contracts, and land purchases made through relatives of officials. Residents who had sold property under pressure came forward after seeing Eleanor on the news. A widower described two men visiting his porch every evening until he accepted a low offer. A mechanic produced photographs of vandalism at his shop after refusing to sell. Their stories turned Arthur’s records from historical documents into evidence of a living pattern.
Eleanor attended none of the early hearings. Lawyers advised her not to, and she had no desire to sit within sight of Snake or Hale. Instead she followed the case through Rachel Kim, who became both attorney and friend. Rachel explained every filing in plain language, including the frustrating delays caused by defense motions and disputes over evidence.
Justice, Eleanor learned, involved far more paperwork than revenge stories suggested.
During one hearing, Hale’s defense team challenged the authenticity of Arthur’s files, arguing that an elderly amateur had gathered material without proper methods. Prosecutors answered with metadata, bank records, third-party business files, and testimony from people whose names appeared in Arthur’s notebooks. The defense then suggested Wrench had manipulated the evidence to obtain immunity. That argument failed when forensic analysts showed copies of the same records existed in Arthur’s bank box months before Wrench knew Eleanor had opened it.
The most painful development came when investigators determined Arthur’s death had almost certainly been natural. Eleanor had feared Snake or Hale somehow caused his heart attack, especially after Arthur’s final video. Medical records, pharmacy logs, and witness statements showed no sign of poisoning or interference. His heart had simply failed after years of damage.