Downstairs, Caleb sat beside the stove until the embers turned red. He listened to the floorboards creak as Ruth moved a chair against the bedroom door. He understood why a frightened person might sleep that way, but he wondered who had taught her to fear a stranger so thoroughly. Before dawn, he rose and checked the horses, then discovered a pair of tiny footprints in the mud beneath his kitchen window. Someone had been watching the house from outside. The prints were too large to belong to June.
At breakfast Ruth said nothing about the chair. She had already washed the bowls, swept the floor, and begun mending a tear in Caleb's work shirt. He told her she was a guest and needn't work. "I'm not much good at being anybody's guest," she replied. June sat on the hearth with a piece of charcoal, drawing a house beneath an enormous sun. The baby's laughter filled the room when Caleb's old collie, Amos, put his nose against the boy's toes.
By afternoon the rain had slowed, but the creek remained impassable. Caleb rode to the ridge to inspect his north fence and found a dead horse in a ravine, its saddle removed and its brand deliberately cut away. Near the animal lay a torn scrap of blue calico, the same pattern as Ruth's skirt. He did not touch it. He returned home by the back trail and found Ruth standing on the porch, searching the hills with her eyes. When she saw his expression, her own face changed.
"Someone is following you," Caleb said. Ruth pressed her lips together and glanced toward the window where June was teaching Amos to shake hands. "I didn't mean to bring trouble here," she whispered. "Then tell me what kind of trouble it is." Ruth looked away. "The kind that doesn't stop when you give it what it wants."
Caleb might have pressed her, but the baby began coughing and Ruth hurried inside. He spent the evening repairing a broken latch on the stable while wondering why a woman carrying two children would choose a mountain road during a storm. At supper he told her the bridge might remain underwater another two days. Ruth's eyes closed in relief before she could conceal it. Caleb pretended not to notice, because he was beginning to understand that staying frightened her less than leaving.
The next morning June found a wooden cradle in the loft above the pantry. It was covered with a sheet, and someone had carved a row of little stars along its rail. She came downstairs excited, asking whether Thomas could sleep in it. Caleb's face went white. Ruth pulled the child close and apologized, but Caleb shook his head. "She didn't know," he said. He walked outside and stayed there until the sun had moved behind the barn.
That evening Ruth found him sitting on the back steps, turning a small brass button between his fingers. "My wife was named Evelyn," he said without looking at her. "Our son was Matthew. He died of fever the week he turned three, and she followed him six days later." He spoke the words without drama, as if repeating an account he had memorized to keep himself from drowning in it. Ruth sat beside him but did not touch his arm. "I'm sorry," she said, and he believed her because she did not try to tell him that time healed anything.