Hattie Renfro began to cry in the second row. Nobody comforted her. Judge Dell was reaching for his hammer when Pike moved. He had seen the whole of his life fall through in 10 minutes, and he went for the one thing in the room that was still worth something.
He caught Nell by the arm at the end of the table and had his pistol out and up before any man closer could turn around. " Back," he said. " All the way back." Caleb stood up.
He had irons on his wrists and nothing in his hands, and he came out from behind the table and walked up the aisle toward that pistol, slow and steady, and he did not stop. " Hail," Pike said. " Hail, I'll do it." Caleb kept walking.
It was Silas Vain who moved first. He came off the prisoner's bench with his guard's hand still on his shoulder and put his whole body in front of the barrel and the pistol went off and the drifter with the burned hand took the bullet that had been 14 years late in finding him. Then six ranchers went over the benches and Vance Pike disappeared underneath them. Nell knelt down in the sawdust.
Vain was trying to say something to her and could not get it out. She took off her shawl and laid it over his face when it was done. She did not say she forgave him. She never did say it.
Then or after, and the men who were in that room agreed for years afterward that it was better that way. The judge cleared the room of everyone but the parties. It was 2:00 in the afternoon before he took the conveyance back up. Barrow was still on his feet.
He had his pen in his hand. He had not sat down through any of it. " Mrs. Hail," he said, "the company will go to $15,000 paid to you alone today." The room got very quiet again because $15,000 was more money than the whole of Sweetwater Bend had ever seen at one time, and because every man still in that courtroom knew what he had done to her on the courthouse lawn in September.
Nell reached into her pocket and took out a penny. She set it down on the judge's table. " My father bid this for my supper," she said, and the town laughed. "" I don't want any man's $15,000."
I want the Notch Dam opened and the water filed as a standing right for every homestead in this basin. Held in trust and not sellable to the company or to anybody. A penny a year from each family. That's the whole price.
She looked at Barrow. " That's the offer. There won't be another." Judge Dell was a long time answering. "
Enter it," he said. He dismissed the charge against Caleb Hail and ordered the iron struck off. He ordered Vance Pike held for the killing of Silas Vain and he ordered Rufus Coulter held for arson and for the death of Ruth Coulter in the year 1865. The town did not turn good overnight.