Mr. Moretti, am I suspected of something? Alessandro could have avoided the question. Instead, he said, "Your access credential was used near my office." The blood left her face. Isaiah's pencil dropped, but I wasn't there.
I know. Naomi stared at him. You know, we checked before we came to you. The fear in her expression did not disappear. It changed shape.
Then someone used my card. Someone used your identity. Alessandro corrected. Isaiah looked from him to his mother. Because of me?
No. But if I hadn't said anything, then I would still have a problem. I simply wouldn't know about it. He looked at Naomi. Until we understand how your old credential remained usable, neither of you discusses this with anyone.
Naomi nodded. Isaiah did not. What if the person asks, "Then you know nothing." Isaiah frowned. But I do know something. Alessandro studied his for a moment, then practiced the most difficult skill in this house.
What? Knowing something and not proving it to everybody, she seemed unconvinced, but Naomi placed a hand gently over hers before she could answer. By evening, the investigation had gained facts, but lost certainty. The rose perfume pointed nowhere specific. Naomi's credential implicated a card rather than Naomi.
The missing destruction record could indicate negligence or intentional theft. Marco's deputy remembered processing several damaged cards the week Naomi's was replaced, but could not recall hers individually. The outside contractor insisted deactivated credentials should never have opened a secured door. Yet, a systems report revealed something Marco had not known. During a software migration 3 months earlier, a batch of old credential identifiers had temporarily been restored from backup.
Most were automatically blocked again. A handful had remained active until the next audit. Naomi's original card was among them. "So, someone didn't need to hack anything," Alessandro said. Marco looked furious.
They only needed the physical card, which was supposed to be destroyed. Yes. And wasn't apparently not. Alessandro closed the report. This was the first meaningful shape the threat had taken.
Whoever had used Naomi's credential did not require extraordinary technical skill. They required familiarity with the house, access to discarded security materials, and confidence that a domestic employees name on a log would either be ignored or blamed on her. It was clever precisely because it was ordinary. Later, when Alessandro passed the kitchen, he saw Isaiah sitting alone with him notebook closed beside his homework. "Why aren't you writing?" he asked.
He looked at the cover. "I thought maybe I shouldn't anymore because of your mother's card." "Because every time I notice something, somebody gets in trouble." Alessandro leaned against the doorway. Your mother didn't get in trouble. He looked scared. He had no useful answer to that.
Naomi had been scared. A person could be innocent and still understand how easily a system could decide otherwise. Isaiah picked at the edge of his eraser. What if I'm wrong about the drink? Then you're wrong.
Would you be angry? No, really. I have people around me who are paid very well and are wrong all the time. Isaiah considered that. Do you tell them frequently?
For the first time since the office incident, he smiled. It lasted only a second. Then footsteps approached and one of Alessandro's assistants appeared carrying a secure envelope. The preliminary lab report came in. Alessandro took it upstairs before opening it.