Relief, profound and overwhelming, washed over him. Caldwell stood in the background, allowing the family their moment before stepping out into the hallway to make a phone call. The time for empathy was over. Now it was time for war. Across town, the atmosphere inside the Oakidge Police precinct was toxic.
Captain Robert Reynolds paced the floor of his soundproofed office like a caged tiger. Sitting at the conference table was Frank Donovan, the union representative for the Police Benevolence Association, a man notorious for his ruthless ability to shield bad cops from consequence. This is a disaster, Rob. Donovan growled, chewing on the end of a cheap unlit cigar. A pregnant woman, dislocated shoulder, emergency C-section.
The optics on this are a nightmare. The media is going to crucify us if this leaks before we have a narrative. Captain Reynolds ran a hand over his bald head, his blood pressure soaring. We don't need a narrative, Frank. We need a miracle.
Do you know who the primary witness is? Harrison Caldwell, the chief federal judge. The man has the mayor on speed dial and the governor on his Christmas card list. He was standing 10 ft away. Donovan scoffed, leaning back in his chair.
He's an old man, Rob. Old men have bad eyesight. Maybe he saw what he wanted to see. From his angle, maybe it looked like Hayes kicked her. But maybe Hayes was just regaining his balance after the suspect violently resisted.
We push the officer safety angle. Hayes thought she was reaching for a weapon in her bag. She fought back. She slipped. Gravity did the rest.
You want to call a federal judge a liar? Reynolds asked in disbelief. I want to protect the department from a multi-million dollar lawsuit and a DOJ consent decree. Donovan snapped back. Here is what we do.
We secure Hayes's dash cam. If the footage is ambiguous, we bury it under a mountain of bureaucratic red tape. We cite an ongoing internal affairs investigation and refuse to release it to the press. We suspend Hayes with pay, let the news cycle blow over, and handle it internally. Reynolds looked sick, but he knew Donovan was playing the game by the established rules of the blue wall of silence.