Mara stared at it. She remembered that school play. She had been twelve, standing behind a cardboard moon in a community center, furious because Evelyn had not arrived before the curtain. Mara remembered looking into the audience during her first line and seeing an empty chair beside the aisle. She had carried that empty chair for twenty-two years.
Three pages later was a note: BLEW REAR TIRE NEAR WINSLOW. LEFT BIKE WITH HARRY. BUS PHX. MADE MARA PLAY 6:52.
Mara sat down on the motel step. Nancy quietly went inside. Shane stood by his truck, uncertain whether to leave. Mara remembered Evelyn appearing after the second scene, hair wet from a bus-station sink, still wearing riding boots. In Mara’s memory, she had been late because the road mattered more. On paper, the road had delayed her and she had crossed half the state anyway. Mara turned another page.
There were initials scattered among mileage notes: C.R. beside a date in 1979. D.C. beside a tow receipt number. Then, written in block letters: HOLD TITLES.
Shane saw her expression. “What?” She angled the notebook away instinctively. “Nothing.”
He gave her a tired look. “You keep saying the number was clean. I know.”
“Then why did you cuff me?” He looked past her toward the road. “Because Carl told me to.” “That supposed to make me feel better?”
“No.” “Good.” Shane opened his truck door. Mara said, “Did Carl write down the VIN before you checked it?”
He stopped. “Why?” “Because he called it wrong before anybody looked twice.” Shane’s face closed.
“That’s not an answer,” Mara said. “No.” He got into the pickup and left. Mara opened the notebook again.
Near the back was a list of six license plates and three names she did not recognize. One had a star beside it: Tommy Reed. The date was 1981, two years before Tommy said he lost his Harley, so it could not be the same incident. Perhaps Evelyn had met him before. Perhaps she had simply collected people the way other riders collected pins.
A folded receipt slipped from between the pages. CROW SERVICE — 1979. Mara turned it over. On the back, in Evelyn’s handwriting, were four words. ASK WHY TITLES HELD. The next morning Paul began pulling county impound logs.
He did it legally, which made the process slower and more revealing. Every request went through a clerk who wanted to know why he needed it. Every photocopy cost money the Gazette did not want to spend. Every time he asked for a tow ticket involving Carl Reddick, someone from the sheriff’s office seemed to hear about it before lunch. Still, paper accumulated.
Carl had referred thirty-seven vehicles to Crow Towing over four years. Most were cars. Nine were motorcycles. Six of those motorcycles had out-of-state plates. Four became “unclaimed” within less than ten days.
Paul spread the copies across Nancy’s motel counter after midnight. Mara pointed at one line. “No certified notice date.” Paul nodded. “Same here.”