Someone who had the authority and jurisdiction to look at what Reese had found and recognize it for what it was. De Sousa's statement went to that same federal contact. So did the police report on Jerold Fenn's accident, along with a detailed memo Reese had prepared documenting Roy Stoller's employment history and his specific connection to the investigation that had cleared the accident as a straightforward distracted driving incident. Pritchard and Coyle retained three separate attorneys in the first week after the motion was filed. All three were from firms that had no connection to Whitmore and Associates, which meant they understood what had already been compromised and we're trying to construct a clean defense at a late stage.
Their first move was a motion to dismiss on procedural grounds exactly as Patricia had predicted. Patricia's response was so thoroughly documented and so precisely argued that the dismissal motion was denied within 72 hours, which was fast enough to make it clear to everyone involved that the bench was paying attention to this case. Their second move was a settlement offer. It arrived through one of the new attorneys delivered to Patricia's office in a sealed envelope and it contained a number that was significant and an attached non-disclosure agreement that was 23 pages long. Patricia brought it to Emily.
Emily read the non-disclosure agreement once top to bottom. Then she set it on the table and looked at Patricia. "If I sign this," Emily said, "what happens to the other families?" Patricia said carefully, "The settlement would be specific to the Walker estate matter. Other cases would not be affected by your agreement."
"But my participation in those cases would be affected." "Yes, the NDA is broad enough to effectively prevent you from serving as a witness or providing a support in any subsequent action related to Pritchard & Coyle." Emily looked at the settlement number. It was more money than she had seen in her entire life. It was more money than she had imagined being offered.
It was the kind of number that could give her back everything that had been taken and then significantly more. And it was sitting in front of her with a pen beside it. She pushed it back across the table. "No," she said. Patricia said, "Emily."
"No," Emily said again, not loudly, not dramatically, with the flat complete certainty of someone who had already worked through the calculation before the offer arrived. There are four other families. There may be more. Accepting this money and signing that agreement means every one of them stays exactly where I was 3 weeks ago. No support, no access to what we found, no path forward.
She looked at Patricia directly. I am not doing to them what was done to me. Patricia studied her for a moment. Then she said, I'll inform opposing counsel that the offer has been declined. She picked up her phone.
Emily stood up and walked to the window and stood there looking out at the city. Marcus, who had been in the corner chair, watched her. He thought about what it cost a person who had been poor and frightened and alone for 5 years to look at a significant sum of money and push it away. He thought about the specific quality of principle required to do that. The kind that was not performance and was not ideology, but was simply the internalized understanding that there were things you did not do regardless of what doing them was worth.