"I wish I hadn't found the car," Noah whispered. Renee's breath caught. "I know you're scared." He nodded, ashamed of the tears on his face. "I keep thinking they'll hurt you because of me." Renee turned him toward her. "The people who did this made their own choices. You did not cause their crimes by saving a life." Noah wanted to believe her. He thought of Charles trapped behind the glass, his hand striking the window, and knew he would break it again. He only wished the world had not become so complicated afterward.
Detective Grant used Noah's photograph to identify one of the men as Victor Shaw, a contractor employed by Northstar Risk. Vehicle records and surveillance footage placed Shaw's SUV near the crash scene, outside Noah's school, and close to the Bennett house on the night of the attack. Investigators also found messages linking Shaw to Martin's assistant and payments from a shell company in the days before the crash. A warrant was issued for Shaw's arrest. He disappeared before officers reached his apartment.
Meanwhile, Celeste received a call from Martin telling her that Charles had ordered an emergency board meeting. He wanted to suspend Martin and invite outside auditors to examine the company. "If he does that, we're finished," Martin said. Celeste replied that she would not help him threaten a child. Martin laughed. "You already helped me. Your signature is on every document." Then he added, "Remember what happened to Andrew when he started asking questions." Celeste froze. Andrew's boating accident had been investigated and ruled accidental, but she had never forgotten how quickly Martin arrived at the marina that day.
Celeste drove to the police station with the recording phone in her purse. Detective Grant listened as Martin described the plan to disable Charles's car and pressured Celeste to help locate Noah. The recordings did not prove that Martin had killed Andrew, but they gave investigators new grounds to examine the older case. Celeste admitted her role in falsifying board records and agreed to cooperate under advice from her attorney. "I told myself I was protecting what Andrew left me," she said. "But I was protecting my place at a table built on other people's losses."
Martin's response to the emergency board meeting was immediate. He issued a company-wide notice claiming Charles was medically unfit to make decisions and that the boy's family was exploiting an elderly man. Anonymous accounts posted Noah's school photograph online, alongside accusations that Renee had manipulated the DNA test for money. Reporters gathered outside the Bennetts' boarded-up house. Some neighbors defended the family; others repeated the rumors. Noah saw one headline describing him as a "mystery heir" and felt as if he had been turned into a product people could argue about.